I agree the Hobie 16 is the more FUN boat. But the guy specifically said 'No pitchpoling'. The characteristics he described are a perfect match for the Supercat 17. The ride is stable (and dull). Not only is the Hobie 16 fun, it is inexpensive for old used boats. Its a great starter boat, if you have a partner to get you familiar with it, before attempting single-handing it.