Catsailor.com

Winglets on trailing edge

Posted By: warbird

Winglets on trailing edge - 09/20/08 11:33 PM

Trying these out today as I have been thinking they are a good idea for years on trailing edge of square tops.
Chance for you to tell me how mentally challenged I am Wouts.

Attached picture 158492-PICT0064.JPG
Posted By: Tony_F18

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/20/08 11:42 PM

Do you have a bigger picture? Cant make out where on the sail this is.
Posted By: arbo06

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/20/08 11:53 PM

Looks like the end of a batten.
Posted By: Timbo

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/21/08 05:11 AM

That looks very much like the wingtips on the Airbus 320 and 310! I have wondered if it would work on a sail. Let us know if you see any difference, I think it might need to be bigger though. http://www.jetphotos.net/viewphoto.php?id=264848

The other thing I have thought about was adding vortex generators to the main about a foot back from the mast, for light air sailing.
Posted By: warbird

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/21/08 06:47 AM

Top batten at aft end of square top.
Designed to lessen drag of vortex. SImilar to eagles wing tips. You will notice they curve up and yes the plane manufacturers are now using them to improve economy.
Yes, they may need to be bigger.
Posted By: scooby_simon

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/21/08 10:50 AM

Quote
Trying these out today as I have been thinking they are a good idea for years on trailing edge of square tops.
Chance for you to tell me how mentally challenged I am Wouts.


How are you going to tie it in?

Don't you need a hole somewhere to tie it into the batten pocket?
Posted By: Inter_Michael

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/21/08 04:39 PM

I think this was talked about some time ago. The topic being winglets, the term used for plane wings. Instead of on the end of a batten, why not the mast itself? The idea of a winglet is not one of added lift, rather it is of decreased drag.

One could make a winglet for a mast that even had some floatation in it, no? Most winglets are on the top surface only, even the airbus has a larger surface on the top, than on the bottom. I think it was conveyed that the winglet on a mast would indeed count towards sail area.

As far as vortex generators go, I don't know that you would get the same effect on a sail as you would a wing. The purpose is indeed for 'slow-flight', but, it is mostly to keep attachment over the aileron.

Might be curious to see this develop thru the years....
Posted By: warbird

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/21/08 06:23 PM

Quote
Quote
Trying these out today as I have been thinking they are a good idea for years on trailing edge of square tops.
Chance for you to tell me how mentally challenged I am Wouts.


How are you going to tie it in?

Don't you need a hole somewhere to tie it into the batten pocket?


Yes, I photographed them the minute I had fitted the batten snugly and just after this photo I marked the holes and drilled them.
All works well.

As it happens a friends giant carbon wing sail was destroyed in a storm last year and I will form the batten out of the sides of that once I have had feedback about size etc. so the weight can be reduced.

Attached picture 158534-2322462947_2875144b1a.jpg
Posted By: warbird

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/21/08 06:39 PM

FYI
Looking at this bird one wonders if the wing on a sail could be a cloth hinged unit that flipped over to the other side on tack as the bird and plane both exit the shape to the "lift" side.

Attached picture 158535-bald-eagle-flight1.jpg
Posted By: Luiz

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 02:49 AM

Quote

Looking at this bird one wonders if the wing on a sail could be a cloth hinged unit that flipped over to the other side on tack as the bird and plane both exit the shape to the "lift" side.


Makes sense. And if the vortex itself isn't enought to tack the winglet, the inversion of curvature of the batten in a tack can generate the force needed to do the job.
Posted By: Jake

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 12:18 PM

Quote
FYI
Looking at this bird one wonders if the wing on a sail could be a cloth hinged unit that flipped over to the other side on tack as the bird and plane both exit the shape to the "lift" side.


In the picture attached, I suspect the feathers on the tip of the eagle's wings are there for stability in slow flight - not efficiency. They may even have very little affect on the airflow but may just be positioned that way to give the bird additional feedback about the airflow conditions on each end of it's wing so it can avoid a stall condition.

[Linked Image]
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 01:39 PM

looks like you lost a little weight in your avitar Jake!
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 03:38 PM

Quote
looks like you lost a little weight in your avitar Jake!


And he gave up smoking....
Posted By: MUST429

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 04:25 PM

I thought that was just how he looked after the Tybee 500.
<img src="http://www.catsailor.com/forums/images/graemlins/laugh.gif" alt="" />
Posted By: Jake

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 05:01 PM

Quote
Quote
looks like you lost a little weight in your avitar Jake!


And he gave up smoking....


I don't need to smoke anymore - I got my a-cat smoking now.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 05:11 PM

I "DIG" them gloves!

You wouldn't want dish-pan hands while fighting crime (yes i am assuming you are a crime fighter... why else wear a cape!?)
Posted By: Jake

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 07:00 PM

Quote
I "DIG" them gloves!

You wouldn't want dish-pan hands while fighting crime (yes i am assuming you are a crime fighter... why else wear a cape!?)


That's what it's all about. Crime and dirty windows.
Posted By: MUST429

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/22/08 07:20 PM

Quote
Quote
I "DIG" them gloves!

You wouldn't want dish-pan hands while fighting crime (yes i am assuming you are a crime fighter... why else wear a cape!?)


That's what it's all about. Crime and dirty windows.


The joker read that and said ... "Why So Seriousssssss"
and then licked his lips and went running off the other direction. <img src="http://www.catsailor.com/forums/images/graemlins/laugh.gif" alt="" />
Posted By: dave mosley

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/23/08 01:28 PM

how do the ice boat masts work? They look like they are warped in some way
Posted By: JACKFLASH

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/26/08 01:23 PM

I should stay out of this since I have absolutely no aerodynamic training, but as I understand it (from years of training on the Discovery Channel) the winglet, as well as those little fins that they stick on the top of plane wings were put in place to keep the air from spilling off the end of the wing thus keeping the flow more front to back and there for making it more efficient. Improved air flow/attachment equals less power needed to generate the same amount of lift.
Posted By: Luiz

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/27/08 08:10 PM

Quote
I should stay out of this since I have absolutely no aerodynamic training, but as I understand it (from years of training on the Discovery Channel) the winglet, as well as those little fins that they stick on the top of plane wings were put in place to keep the air from spilling off the end of the wing thus keeping the flow more front to back and there for making it more efficient. Improved air flow/attachment equals less power needed to generate the same amount of lift.


Winglets are there to help the tip vortex form in the tip of the wing instead of anywhere else, thus keeping the entire wing span effective for more time than without them.
Posted By: ncik

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/29/08 05:10 AM

An alternative theory is that the winglets are designed to "intercept" the vortex at an appropriate angle to produce thrust.

Consider a propeller spinning in a straight flow producing thrust. That's easy to understand because we see it all the time.

Now invert it so that a fixed foil is in a spinning flow. This is the case at the tip of a wing with a winglet attached.

The fluid wants to move from the high pressure side to the low pressure side which generates a vortex/twist in the flow. Put a small foil at a slight angle in the way of this twisting flow and you may be able to generate some thrust.
Posted By: Luiz

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/29/08 03:12 PM

Quote
An alternative theory is that the winglets are designed to "intercept" the vortex at an appropriate angle to produce thrust.

Consider a propeller spinning in a straight flow producing thrust. That's easy to understand because we see it all the time.

Now invert it so that a fixed foil is in a spinning flow. This is the case at the tip of a wing with a winglet attached.

The fluid wants to move from the high pressure side to the low pressure side which generates a vortex/twist in the flow. Put a small foil at a slight angle in the way of this twisting flow and you may be able to generate some thrust.


I really don't know. In fact, my previous post was based on what I could learn from Chapter 3.12 of John Denker's online book "See How It Flies", from where I quote the following:



Quote
[color:"blue"] Winglets encourage the vorticity to be shed nearer the wingtips, rather than somewhere else along the span.[/color] This produces more lift, since each part of the span contributes lift in proportion to the amount of circulation carried by that part of the span, in accordance with the Kutta-Zhukovsky theorem. In any case, as a general rule, adding a pair of six-foot-tall winglets has no aerodynamic advantage compared to adding six feet of regular, horizontal wing on each side.


My view is the following:
Sails are different from wings. A sail tip does not rotate/move due to boat motion/waves at speeds that are relatively high compared to the wind speed. IF winglets help keep the vortex in place, they could possibly boost performance.
Posted By: TEAMVMG

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/29/08 03:37 PM

All the time you blokes have spent looking up, YOUV'E JUST MISSED THE LAYLINE!


Sorry couldn't resist, Carry on, its good stuff [If I only understood it]
Posted By: Jake

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 09/29/08 04:33 PM

Quote
Quote
An alternative theory is that the winglets are designed to "intercept" the vortex at an appropriate angle to produce thrust.

Consider a propeller spinning in a straight flow producing thrust. That's easy to understand because we see it all the time.

Now invert it so that a fixed foil is in a spinning flow. This is the case at the tip of a wing with a winglet attached.

The fluid wants to move from the high pressure side to the low pressure side which generates a vortex/twist in the flow. Put a small foil at a slight angle in the way of this twisting flow and you may be able to generate some thrust.


I really don't know. In fact, my previous post was based on what I could learn from Chapter 3.12 of John Denker's online book "See How It Flies", from where I quote the following:



Quote
[color:"blue"] Winglets encourage the vorticity to be shed nearer the wingtips, rather than somewhere else along the span.[/color] This produces more lift, since each part of the span contributes lift in proportion to the amount of circulation carried by that part of the span, in accordance with the Kutta-Zhukovsky theorem. In any case, as a general rule, adding a pair of six-foot-tall winglets has no aerodynamic advantage compared to adding six feet of regular, horizontal wing on each side.


My view is the following:
Sails are different from wings. A sail tip does not rotate/move due to boat motion/waves at speeds that are relatively high compared to the wind speed. IF winglets help keep the vortex in place, they could possibly boost performance.



I believe that theory can be extended to the difference between old pin head sails and the newer square tops. The difference between the two is not complete to get more sail area up high...rather, on the pin head, as the air spills around the top of the sail on the windward side, it will curl around the back of the sail near the top. With the pin-head, this "leaking" air around the top would wash downward on the leeward side washing out some of the good airflow generating lift. By adding the square head, the amount of air that would leak to the backside is reduced. I believe the winglet takes this to the next step.
Posted By: sbflyer

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/11/08 02:35 PM

I don't know, wouldn't winglets increase the drag to leeward? And all the planes you see them on operate at fairly constant angles of attack, with the way cat masts move around it seems like it would add more drag, for example every time the bows go up and down over a wave it would raise and lower the angle, and keep shaking the airflow off. As a longtime hangglider pilot I've seen different tries at the winglet idea, and nobody has been able to make it work, mostly because every time the wing yaws a little it brings one side to too low an angle as the other side goes to too high an angle. One of those ideas that seem good but that don't work in actual use, maybe?
Posted By: Luiz

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/12/08 02:52 AM

Quote
I don't know, wouldn't winglets increase the drag to leeward? And all the planes you see them on operate at fairly constant angles of attack, with the way cat masts move around it seems like it would add more drag, for example every time the bows go up and down over a wave it would raise and lower the angle, and keep shaking the airflow off. As a longtime hangglider pilot I've seen different tries at the winglet idea, and nobody has been able to make it work, mostly because every time the wing yaws a little it brings one side to too low an angle as the other side goes to too high an angle. One of those ideas that seem good but that don't work in actual use, maybe?


Maybe, maybe not.
Handgliders are closer to boat speeds, but don't have the same problem of flow attching/detaching near the top of the sail (wing tip) due to waves. It could just happen that a winglet would guide the vortex and help the flow remain attached all the way to the top when the sail moves due to waves. I really don't know and my guess is that even an experienced aerodynamics specialist will ask for wind tunnel tests before giving a final answer.
Posted By: Timbo

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/12/08 01:18 PM

I think Luiz has hit on the biggest problem when it comes to winglets on sails or foils on sailboats. We are not operating in "smooth flow" all the time like an airplane is. With the up-down motion of a sailboat going through waves, there is a side loading on the winglet, from both sides, as it goes up and down, and I think that constant change of flow direction will make them quite a bit less efficient than on an airplane wing.

It may just increase drag without any real increase in lift.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/12/08 01:53 PM

Jake, i am not sure you can trust a book on how to fly by John Denver!....
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/12/08 01:54 PM

Ohhhhh, John Denker.....

never mind (spoken in a high pitch voice like Gilda Radner)


[Linked Image]
Posted By: sbflyer

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/12/08 04:55 PM

Hanggliders DO have the same problem of tip attachment, but due to air turbulence, esp. with the variable geometry on taking the twist out...(analogous to the boom vang being tightened) with severe enough separation at one tip leading to a spin...
Posted By: ncik

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/12/08 11:19 PM

The same situation of oscillating flow occurs in America's Cup yachts yet winglets on keels have been on pretty much every boat for the last couple of events...
Posted By: sbflyer

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/13/08 12:40 AM

Those things don't exactly bob around much...and how many AC boat have you seen with sail winglets?
Posted By: warbird

Re: Winglets on trailing edge - 10/13/08 06:55 AM

Quote
Those things don't exactly bob around much...and how many AC boat have you seen with sail winglets?


How many did you see with square tops tin the previous AC event?! They are not exactly quick on the uptake!
I asked the Prada sail designer personally ten years ago why they had no square tops and he said "Oh, too much construction".
Check the top of the new mast of the Big Dog tri. Small winglets I think.
© 2024 Catsailor.com Forums