No rating system is fair for everybody.
Rolf... anyone... and your point is????
Sailors always say this crap... and its just not helpful... The inference you made and the message delivered is off base? Why don't you come out and say it clearly and directly...
Is it not worth playing the racing game because the game is rigged by this unfair rating system?
Some sailors are wining because they take advantage of an unfair rating system?
It's not worth playing the game because the winner is mostly determined by what the conditions were and which are not fixed by the unfair rating system.
Ah... why waste your time... just go out and sail in a circle and pay no mind about the race... don't hit any body.
You don't say this crap this clearly because you don't believe it. You actually know that handicap rating systems can range from simple to the complex and given the complexity that you want to bother with... they do a pretty good job of sorting out the SAILING PERFORMANCE OF THE TEAMS and eliminating a very complex think like a sailboats performance in the environment.
Is handicap racing PERFECT... NO.... Portsmouth (back in the day)... PHRF/Portsmouth today and SCHRS or TEXEL do a pretty good job of handicapping the boats... Could the systems do better... perhaps.. but it will add a lot of complexity.
is it UNFAIR..... NO! (Lots of well meaning people work to make the system as good as possible...)
Handicap Racing is Not Perfect is VERY VERY different then NOT FAIR!
Race, have fun and relax smile
Bingo....
For a racer... the handicap system is the LAST thing to worry about.
For a Regatta organizer... the details of the handicap system chosen is important because it should remain transparent and irrelevant to the racers. That is the OA's job!
If you are worried about how you will perform under one rating system or the other...you have lost the point of the game. You are behaving like a dog gnawing on their tail.... nothing good is going to happen.
I will bet that you won't
Race, have fun and relax smile
Handicap racing gets more boats on the line racing each other... This tends to keep more sailors racing in the long run.. Blather that is
Not Fair undermines this outcome.