Catsailor.com

New Open 20 rule set

Posted By: Capt_Cardiac

New Open 20 rule set - 10/01/11 11:59 AM

I've posted the Open 20 rule set: 1 October 2011 in the F20 forum. After posting the original F20na box rule set there was considerable "discussion" and changes were made. This rule set is designed to govern the upcoming racing season and will be up for reconsideration on 1 October 2012 per the rules. If you are not satisfied with rules please get involved. Sail with the class and help determine any changes in 2012 and build this into a thriving 20 foot class.

the first event is scheduled for 8-9 October 2011 at Key Sailing, Pensacola, FL. The 2012 racing season will be published by 10 January 2012. If you have a regatta you think would like to sponsor an Open 20 event, please contact me. Come out and support!!!

Joe Pocreva
Posted By: BadLatitude1337

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/01/11 02:35 PM

Come out and sail with us next weekend here on Pensacola beach should be lots of fun!!!!
I personally would like the chance to chat with all you 20 owners here at this event. We have been working on this rule set for months now and after talking to around a billion people and sending a trillion e-mails this is the rule set we came up with. Feed back and support is the only way to keep a new class up and running, so please come out to Pensacola beach next weekend for sum good sailing and fun in the sun.
Charlie Trinque
Posted By: RickWhite

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/01/11 06:36 PM

Should I be looking for another class at the Tradewinds?
Posted By: PTP

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/02/11 09:07 PM

I believe so!
Posted By: BadLatitude1337

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/03/11 02:08 PM

yes sir open 20
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/03/11 03:41 PM

Ok well I guess I'll have a free weekend in January.
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/03/11 05:15 PM

I believe I have a kitchen pass for that weekend, but currently no boat to sit on. Not sure if my current pimp will make the journey with his N20
Posted By: Team_Cat_Fever

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/03/11 09:58 PM

Originally Posted by Undecided
Ok well I guess I'll have a free weekend in January.


You can still race N-20 class, Tad. There should be more stock than modded and I can't imagine a stock N-20 wanting to race in open if they had a class.
Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/03/11 10:04 PM

Originally Posted by Undecided
Ok well I guess I'll have a free weekend in January.


It's done - might as well not fight it and sail what you got. Resistance is futile and all of that.
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 12:11 PM

Originally Posted by Jake
Originally Posted by Undecided
Ok well I guess I'll have a free weekend in January.


It's done - might as well not fight it and sail what you got. Resistance is futile and all of that.


Really? "It's done"?

So a ruleset that originated from a small group of sailors wants to race that ruleset and then force it upon a regatta that has a regional draw.

Thanks but I'd rather not participate in a ruleset that I don't agree with nor think is worthy of competing under.

If there's a 20 class - I'll consider coming down. To be honest, Tradewinds in the past haven't been to kind to me in the past. My fault - not the regatta's.

Posted By: TeamChums

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 12:48 PM

Like Todd said, there will likely still be a N20 class to race in. Rick's just accomodating a new class. I think it's great that he is. If it were all N20's with nothing more than aftermarket sails, then I'll race in it. If there are different types of boats, then I'm really not interested.
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 02:38 PM

what do we have that would likely show? a few M20s, the CFR 20 and one or two new F20C?
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 02:56 PM

The M20's and F20C's don't qualify under this new ill-conceived ruleset.

Both are too wide. The M20 would have to carry a jib too.

I don't know anything about the CFR20.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 03:05 PM

Originally Posted by Undecided
The M20's and F20C's don't qualify under this new ill-conceived ruleset.


Don't hold back, how do you really feel?

PS there may be a n20 racing in dundin next sun (Fondrk) for the Sail for cancer if you want to practice
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 05:13 PM

tell Fondrik to put Tradewinds on his list and Hiram's too. There are enough boats in this area to make a N20 class now if they all came out at the same time.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 05:17 PM

i will mention it to him and Dennis if i see them next weekend. I dont plan on racing but i do plan on participating in the event (giving a cash donation).
Posted By: Goclaw

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 05:27 PM

This process is just like giving birth to a baby. To its mom and dad, it is the most beautiful thing under G-d's creation. To the rest of the world, "all babies look like Winston Churchill"!! Please note that the Rule set is a start. It initially results in extending the life of the N20 class that has been abondoned by the manufacturer to allow Open Sails. In the mid and long term, the rules have enough legs to encourage development. If you like the first part but not the second, the class will vote on amendements after year one. The O20 will not prevent "stock" N20 owners from class racing. Just don't forget that "stock" means quite a range of products.

I hope to see you on the water,

Sail Fast, Live Strong

Ken

"Kani Basami"
Nacra 20 (EP sail 483)
O20 (Schurr Sail #8, Glaser Spin, SNU)
"Baby B"
H-Wave
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 05:58 PM

If all you want to do is race with your aftermarket sails then just enter open spin class and be done with it.

This isn't prolonging anything in the N20 class at all.
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 06:42 PM

If it turns the class around or doesn’t does it really matter at this point? To do nothing is without a doubt the death of the class. There was little to no leadership to champion the OD cause, if there were it’s unlikely the class would even be considering the O20 concept. The fact that there is enough energy and enthusiasm left in the fleet to even try something different speaks volumes about those still involved. Apathy is the cancer of our sport and these folks clearly have their heart in the right place. Try to see the positive of their efforts and in the end will it honestly impact the enjoyment of your N20?

Keep in mind Tad deep down you won't find a bigger OD bigot than me but even I can see this effort as a positive.
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 06:49 PM

So now those of us that do want to race OD will now need to buy an OD sail, and then a second aftermarket set to be competitive when there is only an "O20" fleet if I want to be competitive?

Sounds like a GREAT idea to me.

Its no wonder that my motivation to go race is at an all time low!
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:05 PM

You win.
Posted By: mikekrantz

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:06 PM

So what I need to do is set up my F20c with the F18 beams to qualify as an "Open 20"...
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:07 PM

Originally Posted by mikekrantz
So what I need to do is set up my F20c with the F18 beams to qualify as an "Open 20"...


Ewwwww, why would you even want to do that?
Posted By: samc99us

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:19 PM

Yeah, really, why would you want to do that?

I don't have a dog in this fight anymore, I got out because I saw the writing on the wall, so I'll hold back my comments.
Posted By: mikekrantz

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:23 PM

Hey don't hate the player

Hate the game...
Posted By: samc99us

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:25 PM

Guess it would be a simple mod to have a set of F18 beams for your boat, then you could play under these rules and show the flaws contained therein.
Posted By: mikekrantz

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:40 PM

Based on the boats in the garage, it would just take a new set of shrouds, Forestay, and trap wires. Everything else could be cobbled together from the existing boats.

My guess it would be way overpowered upwind and scary fast downwind...
Posted By: Dlennard

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:49 PM

Originally Posted by mikekrantz
Based on the boats in the garage, it would just take a new set of shrouds, Forestay, and trap wires. Everything else could be cobbled together from the existing boats.

My guess it would be way overpowered upwind and scary downwind...


Fixed it for you!
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 07:54 PM

You could always build a version of Steve Clark's openwing for it too. Since the rules don't forbid that either.

(you just have to put a jib on it for some strange reason)
Posted By: Mlcreek

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 08:15 PM

Tad,
Please allow me to ask this. Being new to the game, I can understand your desire for purist in the N20 pursuit, and make it a level playing field. I sailed this weekend with a bunch of top notch sailors and they smoked me at every race. They could beat me with a 14 Hobie, but I still had a good time. I know in time I'll get better. They'll beat me time after time, but I'll keep trying. If we allow a set or given design of sail by different lofts to be used, what is wrong with making the boats more competitive. I mean, who will want to buy a N20 in a couple of years when it's so slow a F16 can out run it. I'm just asking.
Thanks
Forrest N20
Posted By: tback

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 08:26 PM

Originally Posted by mikekrantz
Hey don't hate the player

Hate the game...




Attached picture hatersgonnapanda.jpg
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 08:35 PM

Originally Posted by Mlcreek
Tad,
Please allow me to ask this. Being new to the game, I can understand your desire for purist in the N20 pursuit, and make it a level playing field. I sailed this weekend with a bunch of top notch sailors and they smoked me at every race. They could beat me with a 14 Hobie, but I still had a good time. I know in time I'll get better. They'll beat me time after time, but I'll keep trying. If we allow a set or given design of sail by different lofts to be used, what is wrong with making the boats more competitive. I mean, who will want to buy a N20 in a couple of years when it's so slow a F16 can out run it. I'm just asking.
Thanks
Forrest N20


I don't know where to start with this one.

"new to the game"? If you're referring to me, I've been a N20 owner since 2007, and sailor since 2005. I don't think that qualifies as "new to the game".

Anyone who looks at my record can tell that I'm not interested in winning. I'm not even interested in finishing top half of the fleet. I do want to compete against who I feel are sailors on equal level as me within the fleet.

What I don't want is to sail an open or formula class because some owners just up and decided that it was ok to change the rules. Thats not what I signed up for when I bought the boat, and its not whats going to cause more people to join the class. Go look at the Nacra 6.0 and what they did. Same song, different singer.

As for why would people buy boats that get beat by F16s... I'd imagine that a ton of H16 sailors would take umbrage with that statement. I didn't buy my boat because it was the fastest boat amongst all the choices available. I bought it because it was what I felt was the best boat to do the race that I loved at the time (and the price was pretty damn good).

So the whole goal of changing the rules so people all of a sudden start buying N20's isn't going to work. How is a boat that is split between two classes going to draw in more sailors?

"Gee, I can sail in a 2 boat one design fleet or a 3 boat open sails fleet. This sounds ... awesome."

*rolls eyes*

Whatever - I think its fairly clear what I think on the matter. Once again, this isn't helping me get off the hump and put the boat in the water. In fact, it makes me rather sick to look at my boat and think of this whole situation.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 08:41 PM

Originally Posted by tback
Originally Posted by mikekrantz
Hey don't hate the player

Hate the game...




At first glance, i thought the panda was "mounting" a yellow marshmallow peeps
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 08:52 PM

Alright that is enough. Stop saying the rule change is keeping you off the water. That's not what is keeping you off the water and you know it. In fact you got well pissed off at me about 16 months ago becuase Thart and I were busting your balls about not sailing which predates this rule change by almost a year. The fact that your boat stays in the driveway has absolutely NOTHING to do with the O20 concept. You chose not to sail for reasons that are uniquely your own my friend.

Unless you're willing to lead the charge back into the OD camp, let these people be. The dark cloud that is you is bringing me down, damn... I thought Mark was negative.
Posted By: Will_R

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 09:31 PM

Originally Posted by Undecided
I don't know anything about the CFR20.


It's WAY (I mean like way way WAY) under the weight in this new O/F20 rule. Also, we'd have to put a jib on it. Still not sure why that is a requirement. If they left it open with only a 50m^2 limit, why not make it open to sloop or uni as well?

Originally Posted by mikekrantz
My guess it would be way overpowered upwind and scary fast downwind...


Mike, the CFR is a lot lighter than the N20c, with a taller mast and 8.5' beam. It can be controlled wink Put those beams on, it would be interesting to see how it does. I think the biggest problem would be that it's over the 50m^2 limit.
Posted By: Team_Cat_Fever

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 10:10 PM

Originally Posted by David Ingram
Alright that is enough. Stop saying the rule change is keeping you off the water. That's not what is keeping you off the water and you know it. In fact you got well pissed off at me about 16 months ago becuase Thart and I were busting your balls about not sailing which predates this rule change by almost a year. The fact that your boat stays in the driveway has absolutely NOTHING to do with the O20 concept. You chose not to sail for reasons that are uniquely your own my friend.

Unless you're willing to lead the charge back into the OD camp, let these people be. The dark cloud that is you is bringing me down, damn... I thought Mark was negative.


You're right Ding, but in Tad's defense, at least he doesn't wear spandex in the boat park.
Tad, Maybe the feeling you have when you look at your boat is just that you've realized it may be time for a different boat. I can relate to that.
Posted By: Mark Schneider

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 10:22 PM

Originally Posted by David Ingram
Alright that is enough. Stop saying the rule change is keeping you off the water. That's not what is keeping you off the water and you know it. In fact you got well pissed off at me about 16 months ago becuase Thart and I were busting your balls about not sailing which predates this rule change by almost a year. The fact that your boat stays in the driveway has absolutely NOTHING to do with the O20 concept. You chose not to sail for reasons that are uniquely your own my friend.

Unless you're willing to lead the charge back into the OD camp, let these people be. The dark cloud that is you is bringing me down, damn... I thought Mark was negative.


Love you too sunshine! I have been enjoying the show... Carry on!
(There is nothing that PHRF/Portsmouth or SCHRS doesn't solve here!)
Posted By: Mlcreek

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/04/11 11:53 PM

Tad,
Forgive me, I certainly wasn't speaking of you " as new to the game." I was speaking strickly of myself. As I am new, and simply asking for your reasoning and reason for your position in this matter. I concur with you that I didn't purchase mine to be constantly up grading, but we can't stay stagnant as to advancements.
Forrest N20
Posted By: Mlcreek

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 12:24 AM

Group,
Please allow me to ask these questions, forgive me in advance if this has been discussed or off base.
Why not have a open 20 class and stock or modified stock class, or whatever you choose to call it?
open would be the carbon and 10'
beam boats or M20s
modified 20's would be a stock boat with limited modifications made and allowed only every 3-5 years

This is my question, if a modification is evident in and for a stock 20, only allow it every 3-5 years depending on what the class decides. Allow the members of the class decide what modifications would be allowed in the class by vote. They would control what would be acceptable, and what wouldn't. You could have either one major change and or two minor changes.
This is my thought...some of us 20 owners can't afford to buy new boats to keep up with changes as in the F18 class. Clearly they are making jumps leaps and bounds. Why not limit the changes into major changes, and minor changes. A major change would be sail and or mast change, A minor change would be changes of blocks, or sheets, castings. By keeping the amount and expense down, it allows slow and gradual changes within the fleet, without folks waking up and being suddenly outdated.
I concur and agree with Tad, but also believe that we need to change but in a majority mutually agreed upon direction.
Clearly manufactures aren't concerned about the fleet, as new 20' class boats are being produced. The class needs to dictate the rules and not the other way around.
Thanks for the time to inquire.
Forrest N20
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 12:31 AM

Originally Posted by Mark Schneider

Love you too sunshine! I have been enjoying the show... Carry on!
(There is nothing that PHRF/Portsmouth or SCHRS doesn't solve here!)


Okay that one made me laugh out loud. You're being so quite I just had to give you a jab to make sure you were paying attention.
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 12:35 AM

Originally Posted by Team_Cat_Fever


You're right Ding, but in Tad's defense, at least he doesn't wear spandex in the boat park.


Don't be hatin, there is nothing sexier than a 50 year old fat man getting into his tights in the boat park. That's right ladies I'm doin it all for you. I can't count the number of times I've caught Beth trying to sneak a peak!
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 01:19 AM

Quote
Stop saying the rule change is keeping you off the water.


I never said that. I said that its not exactly making me get over the current lack of motivation to sail that I've had lately.

Maybe if I wore spandex I wouldn't get butt chafe-age as bad as I do.

Quote
(There is nothing that PHRF/Portsmouth or SCHRS doesn't solve here!)


Amazingly I agree with Mark here.

If you want to sail your N20 with aftermarket sails - to the Open handicap fleet with you!

Don't try and redefine the class because you feel butt hurt at getting beat by F18's and F16's.

I got over that a long time ago.
Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 03:56 AM

Originally Posted by Team_Cat_Fever
Originally Posted by David Ingram
Alright that is enough. Stop saying the rule change is keeping you off the water. That's not what is keeping you off the water and you know it. In fact you got well pissed off at me about 16 months ago becuase Thart and I were busting your balls about not sailing which predates this rule change by almost a year. The fact that your boat stays in the driveway has absolutely NOTHING to do with the O20 concept. You chose not to sail for reasons that are uniquely your own my friend.

Unless you're willing to lead the charge back into the OD camp, let these people be. The dark cloud that is you is bringing me down, damn... I thought Mark was negative.


You're right Ding, but in Tad's defense, at least he doesn't wear spandex in the boat park.
Tad, Maybe the feeling you have when you look at your boat is just that you've realized it may be time for a different boat. I can relate to that.


Look at the boat, realize it's time for a different one, and can't figure out how to get there. I've definitely been there.
Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 03:57 AM

Originally Posted by David Ingram
Originally Posted by Team_Cat_Fever


You're right Ding, but in Tad's defense, at least he doesn't wear spandex in the boat park.


Don't be hatin, there is nothing sexier than a 50 year old fat man getting into his tights in the boat park. That's right ladies I'm doin it all for you. I can't count the number of times I've caught Beth trying to sneak a peak!



Oh good gawd. My brain eyes! I'm blind. That's just wrong. We once had to have a sit-down discussion with a fleet sailor because of the attire he chose to wear during / after sailing. That crap was so sheer, we gained insight as to his religious background. wrong wrong wrong. Ding, I expect better. 50 is an excuse for a lot of things, but you're supposed to give us things to look forward to....things like having really tall bushes by the street in your front yard because "every man should be able to walk out his front door and scratch his balls". That kind of stuff....the stuff that allows you to appreciate your aging manhood but doesn't make everyone have to look at it.
Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 12:52 PM

Originally Posted by Jake
Originally Posted by Team_Cat_Fever
Originally Posted by David Ingram
Alright that is enough. Stop saying the rule change is keeping you off the water. That's not what is keeping you off the water and you know it. In fact you got well pissed off at me about 16 months ago becuase Thart and I were busting your balls about not sailing which predates this rule change by almost a year. The fact that your boat stays in the driveway has absolutely NOTHING to do with the O20 concept. You chose not to sail for reasons that are uniquely your own my friend.

Unless you're willing to lead the charge back into the OD camp, let these people be. The dark cloud that is you is bringing me down, damn... I thought Mark was negative.


You're right Ding, but in Tad's defense, at least he doesn't wear spandex in the boat park.
Tad, Maybe the feeling you have when you look at your boat is just that you've realized it may be time for a different boat. I can relate to that.


Look at the boat, realize it's time for a different one, and can't figure out how to get there. I've definitely been there.


Me and Undecided have at least 3.5 more years together.

Wife has to get through with all her various internships, residencies and other bullcrap before I can even broach the topic without getting yelled at.
Posted By: mini

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 01:59 PM

Capt’n,

What are you really expecting to happen here?

There are a fair number of I20 out there. The class is theoretically run by the factory, which as far as I’ve seen does nothing. The few active guys have tried to generate some interest, but cannot even agree to take over the organization themselves (Ding and his apathy comment are spot on)

Now you are tying again to start an F20 class. This was killed in the past by the I20 crowd refusing to compromise. (This is their right by the way.) Your current rule set is now another political BS compromise driven by a few responders (mostly I20 guys I would guess), who if history prevails will never actually join the class anyway, at least in a supporting role. (These guys are bitching now they do not want to race because somebody might have a new sail – and you expect them to come out when the boat next to them might weight 20 lbs less???) You are now far enough away from the I20 rule that they will not change, you eliminate several current designs, and have nothing of interest to present to even a home builder to try and make a boat to fit.

To get new boats into the mix, there has to be 1) An active race schedule already in place, or 2) Some other incentive for a builder to make a boat. The I 20 is the only existing boat that could be qualified to be currently active, unless you throw in a few H20 with spins. Not even the current builder of the I20 is interested in the prospect of helping this. The other reason there are 20’s of other design showing up is to provide a chance to achieve line honors at races. The biggest fastest boat generates press and advertising value for the company/ designer or whatever. Building a politically compromised I 20 will get nothing in the way of interest from any builder and without boats you will not get the racing no matter how many posts you throw out there.

If you really want to race a 20 and get the fleet going then fast, then get off your butt and round up the I 20 guys out there.

Otherwise just open up the B class rules 20 long 10 wide and some limit on sail area – all else goes. See what eventually gets built for line honor boats. It took a long time for the C-class but it is still going.
Posted By: BadLatitude1337

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 02:17 PM

Originally Posted by mikekrantz
So what I need to do is set up my F20c with the F18 beams to qualify as an "Open 20"...


well the sail set and mast are to large but put a n20 mast on it and if the weight is over 350 your good to go
Posted By: BadLatitude1337

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 02:53 PM

Tad do you want to keep over paying for parts from nacra? Win you can by sails from a loft of your choice for half the cost? And put sum development in to them yourself? Nacra does not even support the fleet/OD class anymore. The parts prices will go up due to the fact that they are now special order parts!!!

As for the nacra 6.0 I assume you’re talking about the class dyeing around the time with the whole NA thing. You were not even sailing then how would you know? Take it from me a as I worked at a dealer forever and have sold thousands of nacra parts/boats . The 6.0 class died win the I18/I20 came out its a case of what happens win the factory stops supporting a class.

The N20 is my favorite boat of all time but they will let it die off just like the 6.0!!!
In my opinion the class is gone either way. But I would still like to see a fast 20 foot class.
The N20 is a good starting point for this new class to get off the ground and that’s it. I intend to build a boat to the class specs

Please remember no one if forcing anything on you tad feel free to keep your boat stock and sail in the OD Class if that’s what you like that’s your right. There is a lot more stock 20’s than open 20’s


Posted By: ThunderMuffin

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 03:26 PM

Charlie,

I appreciate what you're trying to do - but the fact of the matter is that you're trying to change the rules that we all originally signed up for when we bought the boats.

Do I like the fact that Nacra won't support the class? No. Do I think that what you're doing is going to fix that? Not at all.

The fact of the matter is that I could go out and buy new aftermarket sails - sure. I could spend $1000 on a new main, new spin or whatever.

Then Captain Moneybags could go out and buy a new set of custom made 3DI sails (or whatever the latest wizzbang material is these days). At least the F18 class has reasonable restrictions on them.

I mean with these rules, you can build a wing and put it on the boat and be perfectly legal to race. How is that going to help the N20 persevere?

I think that there's not much you can do. The Tybee 500's F18 results domination signaled the death knell of the class - and its just going to keep declining. Open sails aren't going to make people buy the boat more than they are now.

BTW, if I wanted to "compete" in the O20, the first thing I would do is pop my deck lids off, and grind out as much material on the inside of the hull as I could to get closer to the 350lbs limit. That would therefore negate my participation in any further OD N20 events.

I don't have so much of a problem with you guys up in Pcola making your own rules to race under. Whatever makes you happy. What I'm more upset at is that this will now apparently split the 20 fleet racing down at Tradewinds, and I can imagine other popular regional events.

But I should probably keep my mouth shut anyways since I've got between little and no motivation to go sailing right now anyways.

Why am I even here?
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 03:27 PM

so why not just coordinate with all the I20/N20 owners and figure out a regatta schedule like almost every other class does? Then you have a class without having to go through all the work to set up an Open or F group?

Was it price or quality control that was the biggest issue with EP?

If the owners decide as a group to make a sailplan change, why not approach EP (as a group) and phase in like they did with the rudders and mid-pole snuffer?

If you're not trying to regain the moniker of "Fastest beachcat on the planet" (or whatever), why are we arguing about changing the boat to make it faster? Why not work on making it (the boat and the sailors) more fun & inviting (Ding's spandex notwithstanding!). I think that would generate far more participation...

I'd have one right now if they only made garages in my deed-restricted neighborhood 6" longer frown

And Tad, I'd be happy to sail with you if MICreek isn't. With as close as you guys are with John and Rick, you could "4-boat" test pretty much whenever with about an hour's +/- travel.
Posted By: PTP

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 08:08 PM

the people who came up with this stuff are trying to maintain the N20 as a viable racing platform. I wasn't into cat sailing at the time, but even with the attempts to maintain the N6.0 class, it still went bye bye because the N20 came out. The N20 was a reasonable boat to jump to from the 6.0. What was the price of a N20 relative to the cost of a new 6.0 at the time?
The issues:
1. the manufacturer doesn't give a crap about the N20 anymore so isn't going to market (or make for that part) the N20. This pretty much eliminates the SMOD aspect of the class. If this is eliminated, then who would keep buying outdated OD sails for them? This further kills the class.
2. there is no other reasonable platform for the "big boys." I would argue that the F20c is not a reasonable alternative to the N20 at this time (or maybe ever).

Join the new wave or die (and still possibly die, but at least then you will have company)


Suddenly occurred to me that now would be a good time for a manufacturer to come out with a reasonably priced 20 footer. No craziness, just a solid 20 footer (overgrown infusion looking sort of deal). Of course they won't make any money though....
Posted By: pgp

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/05/11 08:22 PM

I keep remembering that for a big part of their history, A class cats were homebuilds, out of wood for the most part. They didn't really become hi-tech until they wanted to get below 200 lbs.!

http://www.bandbyachtdesigns.com/worrell.htm
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 01:19 PM

any wealthy folk want to buy the plugs for the N20 and fire off a few sets if PC isn't going to build them anymore?

I agree that there aren't any other 20 foot alternatives that I'm aware of.

If I recall, the I20 wasn't that much more than a N6.0, especially since it already had the spinnaker on it
Posted By: pitchpoledave

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 02:38 PM

Forget it..The F20Carbon is so superior that it has obsoleted all the other 20 footers except maybe the Marstom20..Its a lot of money but well worth every penny. Guys try the f20c out.. It is absolutely brilliant.
Posted By: samc99us

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 02:48 PM

Newsflash: I top of the line, Tybee 500 winner, Tradewinds winner etc. N20 is available for less than $12k now. I sold my boat, easily capable of the same, for less than $9k (older sails). The guys racing these boats are generally bigger (crew weight >400 lbs), and don't have the $33k for a F20c (in general).

I bought the N20 because, at the time, the local fleet size was large, lake sailing and ocean sailing were the predominate racing conditions, for which the N20 is great at. I'm living in a generally light-air location nowadays, with an active N20 fleet, but I sold the boat before moving here and won't be buying another. Why? I don't need a boat capable of supporting a >400 lb crew, making the F18 a much more ideal platform given the large fleet size, and the fact that for $12k I can buy a competitive boat.

If I had unlimited $$$ (working on that part), I'd have a F18 and a F20c, with the later for pure distance racing events where flat line speed is king and the former for large fleet around the buoys racing.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 03:43 PM

Originally Posted by samc99us
and the fact that for $12k I can buy a competitive boat.


What f18 is 12k?
Posted By: ksurfer2

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 03:50 PM

Originally Posted by MN3
Originally Posted by samc99us
and the fact that for $12k I can buy a competitive boat.


What f18 is 12k?


A good competitive used infusion or capricorn can easily be found for around $12K
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 04:15 PM

Originally Posted by ksurfer2
Originally Posted by MN3
Originally Posted by samc99us
and the fact that for $12k I can buy a competitive boat.


What f18 is 12k?



A good competitive used infusion or capricorn can easily be found for around $12K


Gotcha, I thought he (we) were talking new boat costs.
Posted By: PTP

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 07:48 PM

Originally Posted by samc99us
don't have the $33k for a F20c (in general).

seriously. Who has 33k for a cat? Unless you are sponsored and/or can write off the cost of the boat (can the Zhik boat do this?) then it out of reach for the vast majority of people.
Posted By: Mark Schneider

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 08:12 PM

Come on... The cost of the boat is related to the game you want to play. You decide if it's worth it!

If you are pursuing an Olympic Campaign...A Tornado would have set you back about that amount.... Is a T worth it?

Take a look at the Melges 20 class... I think those boats are 50 to 60K... They come with an International racing circuit run by the builder. They have more class racing going on then does the F16 which has years of boats out in the fleets at 1/3 the price. The melges owners think its a good game to play.

The issue is not the cost of the boat per se... rather... Is there a race or set of races that I simply want to win or own the course records for!

The Seacart 30 that we race against on the Chesapeake is simply gone in any race... Hardly a contest unless it's a reachy kind of day. This owner researched the boat (15 world wide) got a deal, made an offer and decided he wanted to own some records and day sail with his wife!. So, it's worth every penny to him. He has owned LOTs of pricey high tech mono's... and says this is the most fun of them all. (We can't figure out why there are not more deep pocket sailors like him... cause we want a ride like our buddy George snagged)

The problem with the new Nacra boat is that there are no obvious races that you can point the thing at. The good news is that a few owners see it differently... Apparently, the quality of the ride is an overwhelming grin. The few races are good enough for them.

Nevertheless... my general rule... It's never about the boat... It is always about the game!

The same point must be made about an Open 20 rule. If the game is interesting enough, prestigious, competitive enough crazy, off the wall, or just of great personal interest to you.... You will play.

Like Dave, I see what these guys are trying to accomplish. There are as they say... lots of ways to skin a cat... My choice would have been to copy the EU and race like they do at CARNAC ...eg handicap... (I think it's a tough sell to say it's a level playing field)

So... IMO... its about the game to play, then the boat and the quality of the ride and then the dollars.. Would you spend any amount of money to compete in a game you don't want to play... Answer NO... Would you spend any amount of money to sail a boat that sails poorly? No... Life is too short.








Posted By: jkkartz1

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 08:35 PM

Originally Posted by Mark Schneider
Come on... The cost of the boat is related to the game you want to play. You decide if it's worth it!

If you are pursuing an Olympic Campaign...A Tornado would have set you back about that amount.... Is a T worth it?

Take a look at the Melges 20 class... I think those boats are 50 to 60K... They come with an International racing circuit run by the builder. They have more class racing going on then does the F16 which has years of boats out in the fleets at 1/3 the price.

The issue is not the cost of the boat per se... rather... Is there a race or set of races that I simply want to win or own the course records for!

The Seacart 30 that we race against on the Chesapeake is simply gone in any race... Hardly a contest unless it's a reachy kind of day. This owner researched the boat (15 world wide) got a deal, made an offer and decided he wanted to own some records and day sail with his wife!. So, it's worth every penny to him. He has owned LOTs of pricey high tech mono's... and says this is the most fun of them all. (We can't figure out why there are not more deep pocket sailors like him... cause we want a ride like our buddy George snagged)

The problem with the new Nacra boat is that there are no obvious races that you can point the thing at. The good news is that a few owners see it differently...

It's never about the boat... It is always about the game!


And Audi sponsors the Melges 20 class.
Posted By: Mark Schneider

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 09:28 PM

Quote
And Audi sponsors the Melges 20 class.


Yep... that is one way to make an event worth doing... a big sponsor to raise the profile of the event! Your point is exactly?
Posted By: jkkartz1

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/06/11 10:03 PM

I'm jealous.

I believe that the Melges 20 has an open sail rule. It sure hasn't hurt their class. But, you folks sitting here arguing among yourselves isn't helping anyone.

In my opinion, stay 1 design. Your Nacra 20's have no equeal. But keep the stock sail dimensions, but allow your choice of sailmakers.

Maybe search out the Cal 20 class. Its a monoslug member of the dead boat society, but due to loyalty of the owners, it is an active class.
Posted By: pitchpoledave

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 12:06 AM

The F20c is not just for distance racing. Its equally good at course racing..I actually thing its an easier boat to sail than an F18. Sheet loads are higher but its more forgiving and the lift from the foils keeps you out of a lot of trouble.

And speaking of distance racing..It seems that in europe they are doing a lot of it. Why not the interest here? I don't mean the extreme events like the Tybee but shorter 2 or 3 day ones.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePeoEpEbfd4
Posted By: TeamChums

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 12:10 AM

Quote
In my opinion, stay 1 design. Your Nacra 20's have no equeal. But keep the stock sail dimensions, but allow your choice of sailmakers.



DING DING DING DING!!!! We have a winner!

That's all I want to see happen.

Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 01:36 AM

Originally Posted by TeamChums
Quote
In my opinion, stay 1 design. Your Nacra 20's have no equeal. But keep the stock sail dimensions, but allow your choice of sailmakers.



DING DING DING DING!!!! We have a winner!

That's all I want to see happen.



I agree with that too.
Posted By: samc99us

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 11:24 AM

Originally Posted by pitchpoledave
The F20c is not just for distance racing. Its equally good at course racing..I actually thing its an easier boat to sail than an F18. Sheet loads are higher but its more forgiving and the lift from the foils keeps you out of a lot of trouble.

And speaking of distance racing..It seems that in europe they are doing a lot of it. Why not the interest here? I don't mean the extreme events like the Tybee but shorter 2 or 3 day ones.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePeoEpEbfd4


I would love to see more 2 days distance racing events that aren't just "straight line" events. There's 1 on the bay, and a few in the Keys (Steeplechase etc.), but Key Largo/Key West is a long, long way to go for many. I would like to see a race in the Tampa Bay area, possibly one in the Charleston area, and maybe another could be done on the North Carolina 100 course but using the ICW instead of the Harlow Canal to eliminate the need to take the mast down.
Posted By: orphan

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 11:31 AM

There used to be two great distance races on Tampa Bay. Macho man. Davis Island to Dunedin. And one of my favorites "Run What You Brung". Dunedin to Anna Marie. Spend the night and Anna Marie to Dunedin the following day. With enough interest maybe they could be resurected.
Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 12:25 PM

Originally Posted by samc99us
Originally Posted by pitchpoledave
The F20c is not just for distance racing. Its equally good at course racing..I actually thing its an easier boat to sail than an F18. Sheet loads are higher but its more forgiving and the lift from the foils keeps you out of a lot of trouble.

And speaking of distance racing..It seems that in europe they are doing a lot of it. Why not the interest here? I don't mean the extreme events like the Tybee but shorter 2 or 3 day ones.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePeoEpEbfd4


I would love to see more 2 days distance racing events that aren't just "straight line" events. There's 1 on the bay, and a few in the Keys (Steeplechase etc.), but Key Largo/Key West is a long, long way to go for many. I would like to see a race in the Tampa Bay area, possibly one in the Charleston area, and maybe another could be done on the North Carolina 100 course but using the ICW instead of the Harlow Canal to eliminate the need to take the mast down.


Charleston would be such a great place to race a distance race. There is so much to race around and see. Though we haven't talked about a distance race, James Island Yacht Club is itching to have some catamaran racing back there. The amount of container shipping going in and out of there has been greatly reduced in the last year or so too (this used to be a pretty sizable issue and sailors in our area have recorded some close calls in the past). There is also an active group of College of Charleston catamaran sailors sailing out of Fort Moultrie.

We've got contacts at the Aquarium on the waterfront across the harbor from James Island and great beaches to race to just outside the harbor. Isle of Palms to the North and Folly Beach to the south.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 01:25 PM

Originally Posted by orphan
There used to be two great distance races on Tampa Bay. Macho man. Davis Island to Dunedin. And one of my favorites "Run What You Brung". Dunedin to Anna Marie. Spend the night and Anna Marie to Dunedin the following day. With enough interest maybe they could be resurected.


They held a Macho man here 2 years ago, there was a decent turn out...
Posted By: ksurfer2

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 01:34 PM

Originally Posted by MN3
Originally Posted by orphan
There used to be two great distance races on Tampa Bay. Macho man. Davis Island to Dunedin. And one of my favorites "Run What You Brung". Dunedin to Anna Marie. Spend the night and Anna Marie to Dunedin the following day. With enough interest maybe they could be resurected.


They held a Macho man here 2 years ago, there was a decent turn out...


It was held this past spring too.
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 01:35 PM

Didn't we sail Macho this year? Or was that the "unofficial" macho?

It's been running for years, as has the Hangover in Tampa Bay. If people are complaining there's not enough distance races, how come attendance has been down at most of the distance events?
Posted By: waterbug_wpb

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 01:36 PM

Originally Posted by ksurfer2
It was held this past spring too.


You beat me to it....quitter smile
Posted By: samc99us

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 01:57 PM

Alright, well, if anyone needs crew for these events I will fly in. "Run what you Brung" sounds like a great event that should be resurrected!
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 02:03 PM

Originally Posted by waterbug_wpb
Didn't we sail Macho this year? Or was that the "unofficial" macho?

It's been running for years, as has the Hangover in Tampa Bay. If people are complaining there's not enough distance races, how come attendance has been down at most of the distance events?


My bad.. it was this spring.. seemed longer ago.

This event did not have any NOR or race committee.

This years hangover did not happen. There was a lack of interest and support and the fleet basically couldn't cover it's own insurance costs. Bob Barton pulled all the fleet together for beer and burgers at his pool and they resurrected the fleet and have had some races.

Next Sunday is the Barton Sail for Cancer and will probably be a 25 mile distance race for the big boats (causeway around anclote) if it's like his past races.
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 02:25 PM

Originally Posted by samc99us
Alright, well, if anyone needs crew for these events I will fly in. "Run what you Brung" sounds like a great event that should be resurrected!


It never really died, it's always been an underground type of an affair (on purpose). There is no OA, NOR or SI's just a bunch of rif raf getting together for a sail. Pick a date in the spring.
Posted By: catman

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 04:58 PM

Originally Posted by MN3
Originally Posted by waterbug_wpb
Didn't we sail Macho this year? Or was that the "unofficial" macho?

It's been running for years, as has the Hangover in Tampa Bay. If people are complaining there's not enough distance races, how come attendance has been down at most of the distance events?


My bad.. it was this spring.. seemed longer ago.

This event did not have any NOR or race committee.

This years hangover did not happen. There was a lack of interest and support and the fleet basically couldn't cover it's own insurance costs. Bob Barton pulled all the fleet together for beer and burgers at his pool and they resurrected the fleet and have had some races.

Next Sunday is the Barton Sail for Cancer and will probably be a 25 mile distance race for the big boats (causeway around anclote) if it's like his past races.


Actually, there was no Hangover because the TBCS didn't purchase insurance. Therefore no promotion, no race. The fleet has plenty of money, in fact it could buy insurance for the next ten years without taking in a dime and still have money, it just needs what any club needs, the people that are willing to spend their time to help.

The Macho Man is a run what you brung race. It is a TBCS event. The race has gone since the early 90's as I recall. Basically no rules. First boat back wins period. You can hang as much sail as you want etc. The only rules are the boat must have at least two people and you need to stay out of the Macdill AFB exclusion zone. (I have photographic evidence of all you violators from last year). Oh yea, no entry fee.
Posted By: Team_Cat_Fever

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 06:45 PM

Originally Posted by Jake
Originally Posted by TeamChums
Quote
In my opinion, stay 1 design. Your Nacra 20's have no equeal. But keep the stock sail dimensions, but allow your choice of sailmakers.



DING DING DING DING!!!! We have a winner!

That's all I want to see happen.



I agree with that too.


You weren't very keen on it when I proposed it a few years ago.
Posted By: David Ingram

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/07/11 06:48 PM

Originally Posted by Team_Cat_Fever

You weren't very keen on it when I proposed it a few years ago.


It must have been you. Nah! that couldn't have been it you're one of those people that has to be liked by everyone.

Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/08/11 01:29 AM

Originally Posted by Team_Cat_Fever
Originally Posted by Jake
Originally Posted by TeamChums
Quote
In my opinion, stay 1 design. Your Nacra 20's have no equeal. But keep the stock sail dimensions, but allow your choice of sailmakers.



DING DING DING DING!!!! We have a winner!

That's all I want to see happen.



I agree with that too.


You weren't very keen on it when I proposed it a few years ago.


I was for modernizing the sail plan but I preferred a one design fashion with one manufacturer because I feel like it fits a niche that is not very available now in the other classes (but I think might have a slight resurgence in the next several years). Compared to the wide open thought that is out there now, I definitely would rather see a standard sail plan rule open to any manufacturer and leave the rest of it one design (except for the snuffer - that thing sucks).

Open sail makers can be cost effective but there is an economy of scale. The N20 does not offer enough numbers that sail makers will willingly foot the development bill for developing a sail that they can market as "faster" or "better" like they do in F18. Because of that, I have a sense of being lost in the forest and choosing a sailmaker is a tough call.
Posted By: bacho

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/08/11 10:10 PM

Originally Posted by TeamChums
Quote
In my opinion, stay 1 design. Your Nacra 20's have no equeal. But keep the stock sail dimensions, but allow your choice of sailmakers.



DING DING DING DING!!!! We have a winner!

That's all I want to see happen.



+ whatever.
Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/09/11 03:03 PM

Originally Posted by bacho
Originally Posted by TeamChums
Quote
In my opinion, stay 1 design. Your Nacra 20's have no equeal. But keep the stock sail dimensions, but allow your choice of sailmakers.



DING DING DING DING!!!! We have a winner!

That's all I want to see happen.



+ whatever.


Bacho - who are you? We're in the same town. Turkey Shoot regatta on Lake Keowee at the end of the month. We should have a decent multi-hull fleet. Join us!
Posted By: bacho

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/09/11 04:33 PM

My name is Bach. I think I will be out of state for that event but I plan on Last Cat on Keowee and Alter at Nigel's house.

I am VERY new to the N20. I just bought it upgrading from a Hobie 18, I will be sure to take last place at all events but hey, gotta do my time.
Posted By: Jake

Re: New Open 20 rule set - 10/09/11 04:44 PM

Originally Posted by bacho
My name is Bach. I think I will be out of state for that event but I plan on Last Cat on Keowee and Alter at Nigel's house.

I am VERY new to the N20. I just bought it upgrading from a Hobie 18, I will be sure to take last place at all events but hey, gotta do my time.


Ahhh! Bach. I know you. I was wondering who was in Greenville. A N20 - cool. You'll enjoy that. See you at those events.
© 2024 Catsailor.com Forums