Catsailor.com

MY VIEWS ON CATSAILING

Posted By: catsailorp19mx

MY VIEWS ON CATSAILING - 11/06/01 01:57 PM

At the risk of "having my head chewed off" because I may hurt someone's feelings, I am going to use this forum for what it was intended....express my opinion.
<br>
<br>As I see it, there are numerous factors that have contributed to the decline of the "beach cat". Most, if not all, have already been covered on this forum. If I had to pick "just one" factor, it would have to be priorities. If the heart thumping rush you get, when you and your cat leave the beach to go play with Mother Nature, isn't enough to make this a MAJOR PRIORITY in your life....the rest of your excuses won't matter.
<br>
<br>Most forms of recreation involve the spending of money. Dollar for dollar, if catsailing is your priority, you get excellent return on your investment.
<br>
<br>It has to be a state of mind. It starts the night before you go sailing; you don't even think about hooking up the trailer, the drive to the beach, stepping the mast, rigging, because it is all part of the experience. YOU HAVE A PRIORITY!
<br>
<br>Sorry if I rambled...Forecast is mid-seventies...15-20mph.
<br>Boat is hooked up, priority calls.
<br>
<br>Thank you
<br>Dave<br><br>

Attached File
3600-  (21 downloads)
Posted By: Ed Norris

right on, Dave! But we're .... - 11/06/01 05:40 PM

...thinking about why the number of people currently having this priority is shrinking. Basically I see it as two distinct categories of efforts; "new blood" and "fighting attrition"
<br>
<br>Many factors like beach acess, organizational support, etc etc have effects on both efforts, some, like "starter boats" and "ongoing costs" and "Critical Mass" effect one more than the other. We're trying to butts remedies to as many of these as possible and get people working on them, and, again in my opinion, BEFORE the Boomer echo generation gets away from us.
<br>
<br>Ed
<br>
<br>PS BTW, I sailed a P19 this summer, nice boat!<br><br>(To Email me, take the Ihatespam. out of the domain in my displayed email.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: MY VIEWS ON CATSAILING - 11/06/01 06:10 PM

You really want to know what's happened to cat sailing?
<br>
<br>In all our glory, our society has tried to perfect the perception of instant gratification. It's present in all we do. For the last 15 years, PWC's have become the norm because they are cheap ($3k - $6k), take almost no rigging time, and give enjoyment without having to spend $700 on new parts every few years. Granted, Beach Cats last for decades where they last for a few years, but at half the cost, cheap up-keep, and nominal preparation time, PWC's have become the norm. This is all due to our society's hunger for instant gratification with minimal personal contribution or sacrifice.
<br>
<br>Just my $0.02
<br>
<br>Andy Pipkin <br><br>

Attached File
3608-  (21 downloads)
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: MY VIEWS ON CATSAILING - 11/06/01 06:12 PM

Most of all, it takes brains to sail. Not jsut any idiot can jump on a H16 and take off and have a blast. PWC's offer the stupid-proof solution to all those inpatient people out there who think they are enjoying the outdoors when they are actually destroying it.
<br>
<br>Andy<br><br>
Posted By: catsailorp19mx

Re: MY VIEWS ON CATSAILING - 11/06/01 06:48 PM

Andy...You have a strong point. I looked back on all the frustration I had when I first started sailing, and can understand why your average Joe would give up. Is it because there are that many people, that don't want to put in the effort it takes to become a sailor? Have they not applied themselves to anything in their lives?
<br>Dave<br><br>

Attached File
3611-  (21 downloads)
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: MY VIEWS ON CATSAILING - 11/06/01 08:26 PM

Hobie has made billions on us. If they were to provide 2-3 Waves (used 14's or ?) to each fleet , experienced members could take turns training the young ones 8-18 yrs old. This is the time to start ,like I am doing with my grand daughter (8 yrs. old). The sport is down a lot and will die if we do not pass this on to our kids. These boats could sold at the end other the year and replaced at beginning of season. This should give Hobie a tax right off?
<br>
<br>
<br>Doug Snell
<br>H17 Sport #6325
<br>"Stress Free"
<br><br><br>

Attached File
3612-  (16 downloads)
Posted By: basket.case

Re: MY VIEWS ON CATSAILING - 11/06/01 11:00 PM

right on. you do not have to think to run a power boat or a pwc.<br><br>
Posted By: hobie541

Blah, blah, blah! But what have YOU done lately? - 11/06/01 11:44 PM

Have you ever noticed that all the excuses we come up with involve factors outside of us as individuals?
<br>
<br>Here is a non-exclusive list of some of the excuses:
<br>
<br>not enough beach access
<br>too expensive
<br>not enough time
<br>mixed up priorities
<br>too difficult
<br>blah blah blah!
<br>
<br>So here's my question: What have YOU done to promote this sport lately? Not what has Hobie Cat done, or what has Rick White done, or what has Murrays done, or what has [fill in blank] done, but what have YOU done?
<br>
<br>I bought my VERY FIRST CATAMARAN in August of 1998. A beat up Hobie 16 for $500. Why did I buy my first boat? If you want to know why then read the credits of the Rick White videos that we made. The basic story is that a great friend of mine introduced me to the sport, and said, Hey, why don't you go to Hi Tempo (our local dealer) and see if they have any cheap boats. He even spotted me a short term loan to buy it! What a guy! Everyone should have friends like that, that's for sure.
<br>
<br>Anyway, if you want to see our sport grow, then stop making excuses and DO YOUR PART! Make it a committment that you're going to at least take one person per month out on your cat WHO HAS NEVER BEEN SAILING BEFORE. I've done it, it's not that hard! In fact the most fun I had was driving out to a Lutheran summer camp where I used to be a counselor with my boat. I took home sick campers for rides, and they had a blast! Didn't take them long to forget about being home sick when we flew a hull!
<br>
<br>Then, once you can say you're doing your part, then go and approach Hobie, and the dealers, and give suggestions on how you can help them make the sport grow.
<br>
<br>All in all, don't be an arm chair quarterback about this, DO SOMETHING!
<br>
<br>By the way, Dave, please understand that when I say "you" I mean that in the collective sense, so don't take it personally!
<br>
<br>Fair winds from the great soon to be white North,
<br>
<br>Tim J.
<br>
<br><br><br>Hobie 20 #541
<br>Bald Eagle Yacht Club, Fleet 52
<br>White Bear Lake, MN

Attached File
3619-  (20 downloads)
Posted By: catsailorp19mx

Re: Blah, blah, blah! But what have YOU done lately? - 11/07/01 12:43 AM

Hi Tim:
<br>
<br>Just got back from a wonderful sail. Just a tad under 80 degrees, and a steady 15-18. Ah, so nice to live on the coast of Florida and sail year round.
<br>
<br>I don't feel that you would intentionally make a statement about someone that you did not know, in a negative light.
<br>As I stated in my original post, I wanted to express an opinion. That opinion centered around "one" of the numerous factors that we feel contribute to the decline of the beach cat use.
<br>
<br>My point was that if catsailing is not a priority in one's life, then what does it matter if you can't find a place to launch, find the price of cats are too expensive, have a problem finding time, can't afford new sails..............?
<br>
<br>In my post, I made no reference to Hobie Cat, Rick White or Murrays. That was someone else's post.
<br>
<br>Ask anyone on this forum, that knows me, and you will find that I promote catsailing in our area with a cause. Since I sail on an average of 2 to 3 days a week,year round, I don't spend too much time in that armchair.
<br>
<br>Dave<br><br>

Attached File
3620-  (18 downloads)
Posted By: hobie541

I'm replying to this thread as a whole, Dave - 11/07/01 02:19 AM

Hey Dave,
<br>
<br>I knew there might be confusion as to who or what I'm replying to. I'm just weighing in on this idea as a whole of the decline of cat sailing.
<br>
<br>I've seen you post many times, and know that you promote the sport. This is actually a thread I've thought about starting many times, but just haven't had the energy!
<br>
<br>I just hope a few people read this and realize that we're all responsible to the decline or increase of our sport, both collectively and individually!
<br>
<br>Cheers!
<br>
<br>Tim J.<br><br>Hobie 20 #541
<br>Bald Eagle Yacht Club, Fleet 52
<br>White Bear Lake, MN
Posted By: Ed Norris

Action and Talk - 11/07/01 05:22 AM

Err... strongly put Tim, but to the point. We do do a lot of talking here. Buried in all that, tho, some things are actually going on. I've tried to encourage, more than demand, by starting in on this issue. "From each according to their abilities..." an all that. Quite a few of the comments on this thread have sparked clearer thinking among all of us as to avenues worth exploring. And I'm convinced some actions are coming of this whole thing.
<br>
<br>Also, and I think this is important, while you're absolutely right, we can all make a difference by choosing to purposely work at building up our sport, and we shoud do so; nobody had to 'make a commitment' to catsailing in its heyday- it just happened for reasons of its own, which we're trying to ID and where possible, re-create. "Getting commitment" is fine and, at this stage, even essential, but if a group of committed individuals is the only thing driving a 'thing' then that thing's growth is self limiting. When it reaches a certain size where adherants don't feel threatened with the 'decline' of their 'thing' then they don't tend to feel as committed any more. More effective in the long run to identify and use structures, methods, markets, styles etc, that make the sport compelling enough to grow 'virally' by one enthusiastic new convert hooking others.
<br>
<br>Yes I know this 'viral' factor is operative today, but attrition is apparently more operative, so we could stand to make things even more compelling!!!
<br>
<br>As for my own small effort: (Beside taking new people out whenever I can - I've even invited jetskiers out for a blast - and enthusiastic participation in our clubs annual event with a school for CP kids)
<br> I'm most of the way through setting up a doable plan for every major regatta wherein: a) every racer's hometown paper will get a PR saying, "[Hometown] resident [racer] [{participated}{placed ___}] in championship Sailboat racing in [venue].... and b) 4 or 5 nearby local papers to each event will get one before the event, to the effect "National/international/world class Sailboat Racing comes to [venue] and one after, optionally, with a URL for the publisher to get pictures.
<br>
<br>Each story will briefly describe the exciting nature of Catsailing in general, and a paragraph or two about racing, too! Each hosting org. may elect to submit a "contact" to appear in the closing lines of the story optionally "...to meet some enthusiastic recreational sailors in this area, and [get started in this fun sport/get a look at these exciting boats up close/you pick it.]"
<br>
<br>I propose to hire one or more university's PR insource or outsource - they all have the newspaper Dbases, keyed by zip code, so they can send out little squibs every time some freshman gets outta bed three days running. My paper gets 'em by the bucketload. If we use an in-house resource, we, or a manufacturer, could pay in lessons, support or boats. We're only talking a couple thou a year for the whole job, here. Boilerplate stories, fill in the blanks mail-merge 'n database, one form for the P.R.O. or local club to fill out with attendees, line honors, contact info - hell, data collection could be done online, speeding turnaround, automating the process, cutting costs.
<br>
<br>Give me your ideas on what these boilerplate stories should say!
<br>
<br>Regards,
<br>
<br>Ed Norris
<br>
<br>(To Email me, take the Ihatespam. out of the domain in my displayed email.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re:pwc - 11/07/01 06:21 AM

hey, I think the average pwc owner is looking for some excitement, the reason they don't own a cat is because they haven't been exposed, ie: you can see a pwc and one day just decide to go get one they aren't hard to learn to drive,(leaving all the rules of the water aside of course)
<br>now you see a cat go screaming by the beach and you think cool! but you don't think "I'm gonna get me one of those", since you don't sail and have no easy way to learn.
<br>my friend who shall remain nameless (Chris) was going to buy a pwc, I said come for a ride on my H16, he did and no longer wants a pwc, he has joined my fleet (204) 2 years in a row and he still hasn't bought a boat yet. we're working on that though.
<br>my target for conversion next summer is already a pwc owner, although he didn't use it at all this year(can you picture not using your cat for a whole summer?) I'm sure he'll be an easy conversion.
<br>
<br>from all this I conclude, put a new person on your boat, take the time to teach them the basics, and make sure they have fun, and I stress fun, don't over-do it the first time don't yell at them when they screw up. Of all the new people I've had on my boat the number one thing said (by them) is I'm sorry, I can never understand this and I always tell them so. I tell fist time crew a few rules,
<br>1. stay with boat
<br>2. have fun
<br>3. pull that string when I say sheet in
<br>4. let it out when I say sheet out
<br>5. have fun
<br>6. smile, this is the most fun you'll ever have for free!
<br>7. if your not having fun yet read the rules again.
<br>Tim
<br>"Cheech" fleet 204 syracuse ny
<br>[Linked Image]<P ID="edit"><FONT class="small"><EM>Edited by cheech on 11/07/01 12:28 AM.</EM></FONT></P>

Attached File
3635-  (18 downloads)
Posted By: catsailorp19mx

Re: Action and Talk - 11/07/01 11:18 AM

Ed:
<br>
<br>What are your views concerning the strong emphasis on "racing", with respect to cat sailing? I know, for a fact, that the decline in the sizes of our local fleets were effected by it. (of course, there were other factors as well). As a new catsailor, going back 8-10 years, I remember going to fleet meetings and feeling lost because of the racers . Every meeting revolved around racing. A lot of "recreational sailors",
<br>as I was at that time.......felt very left out. Do you think that catsailing is perceived as a "have to race" sport? Just a thought.
<br>
<br>Dave<br><br>

Attached File
3640-  (17 downloads)
Posted By: Kevin Rose

Re: Action and Talk - 11/07/01 12:53 PM

Dave,
<br>
<br>Thanks for asking the question about the emphasis on racing. As I read through this latest thread, I found myself comparing the rise and fall of catamaran sailing to windsurfing. In the beginning, there were the “radical” enthusiasts at the fringes playing with something new and exciting. As time went on and the sport became visible on the water, it began to go mainstream. Windsurfing shops were opening all over. Here on Lake Champlain, rooftop rack-mounted boards could be seen on cars all over town. Everyone wanted to try it. The sport began to mature and the big early model and beginner boards began to disappear. The sport went high-tech. Performance of the boards and sails increased dramatically. No longer was one board/stick/sail combination enough. It got more and more expensive. The mainstream was left behind. Windsurfing returned to its roots at the radical fringes.
<br>
<br>It would seem that we’ve seen the same transition with catamarans. Over the years the cats have gotten pretty high-tech and fast – influenced by the racing community. Unless someone has already been hooked, however, the racing scene can be pretty intimidating. Racing can be endless fun and heart-pounding excitement that includes a lot of camaraderie among sailors, but it’s usually not the place for the beginner to jump in comfortably. The boats and the rules of racing can intimidate the beginner. There are just too many strings to pull for the uninitiated.
<br>
<br>What I’ve found so enjoyable about sailing is the combination of art and sciences that can be taken progressively to higher levels, but let’s not forget about the beginners. They need opportunities for easy, fun entry into the sport that may or may not include racing.
<br>
<br>Cheers,<br><br>[Linked Image] Kevin Rose
<br>N6.0na #215
<br>kevin@paddleways.com
<br>

Attached File
3643-  (16 downloads)
Posted By: catsailorp19mx

Re: Action and Talk - 11/07/01 01:52 PM

Kevin:
<br>
<br>I may be "way out in left field" with this, but has anyone toyed with the idea of having "some" of the local races inlude "mixed teams"? Say, a seasoned racer coupled with a prospective sailor. Regular crews may not like giving up their position, and there would be other factors to deal with. But if the prospective sailor were given the opportunity to participate, just maybe.......Like I said, "probably out in left field", but it does provoke thought.
<br>
<br>Dave<br><br>

Attached File
3645-  (21 downloads)
Posted By: hobie541

Racing v. Recreational Sailing - 11/07/01 02:13 PM

You've jarred my memory as to another aspect of my entrance into the sport.
<br>
<br>When I bought that $500 1975 Hobie 16, I had a blast that first summer, but thought, gee it really stinks to have to trailer this, set it up, and tear it down every time. That mast is really big, I thought! So I started asking around to find a place to keep it rigged.
<br>
<br>That started with calling people who rented out dock space. "You want how much????, That's more than the boat cost!!" So, that didn't last long. Then I finally happened upon my local dealer, and he handed me a brochure for the Bald Eagle Yacht Club aka Hobie Fleet 52. He explained to me that this yacht club had no club house, membership dues of $50 at the time, and that they would find me a place to keep my boat.
<br>
<br>"And how much does that cost," I asked.
<br>"Nothing," he replied
<br>"Nothing?" I asked, "What do you mean, nothing?"
<br>"You just have to show up for at least half the races to stay in the good graces of the property owners," he replied.
<br>
<br>So, to make a long story short, that's how I got hooked on "recreational racing." It's a blast, we have fun, and don't take ourselves too seriously (except every now and then!). That's another thing that falls under the "what can I do" category. The philosophy of our fleet is that it's all about the people, not about clubhouses or facilities. The other part of it is that people who are members of the fleet, and own property on the lake, feel that the only way they're going to get good participation is to give people a spot to put their boat. When I first heard about racing fleets, I thought, what would I want to have to do with a bunch of racers? I'm a novice, and I don't know anything! The incentive was a place to keep the boat! Turned out to be one of the best groups of people I've ever become involved with.
<br>
<br>If you own property on water, think of this as yet another thing that you can do. As a non property owner, I try to be "Johnny on the spot" when it comes to helping my host put his dock in, take it out, and help with whatever else I can. I think it's a pretty generous thing for him and the other property owners to do, and hopefully I will be able to return the favor some day.
<br>
<br>Anyway, the point is, we've got to get people involved in recreational racing for the survival of the sport. I know that I've had just as much fun (err, almost) off the water as on the water with friends in the sport.
<br>
<br>Fair winds,
<br>
<br>Tim J.<br><br>Hobie 20 #541
<br>Bald Eagle Yacht Club, Fleet 52
<br>White Bear Lake, MN

Attached File
3647-  (19 downloads)
Posted By: Kevin Rose

Re: Action and Talk - 11/07/01 02:50 PM

Dave,
<br>
<br>In our fledgling fleet, we quite often have a “prospective sailor” crewing. There are several times when crew members can’t make it and we’re scrambling to find a body. Sometimes it’s a person who wanders by and shows interest.
<br>
<br>If racing were the first introduction, I would guess that it would take a few outings for the prospective sailor to get comfortable and start getting really excited. Jumping on a boat and heading out to the start can be pretty overwhelming for some. The thing that we want to demonstrate is how easy it is to start sailing while having lots of opportunities to grow.
<br>
<br>Cheers,<br><br>[Linked Image] Kevin Rose
<br>N6.0na #215
<br>kevin@paddleways.com
<br>

Attached File
3650-  (15 downloads)
Posted By: Keith

Re: Action and Talk - 11/07/01 03:53 PM

On the racing verus non-racing thing. For our Fleet, having the racing on a weeknight is a help. Most people with families and other obligations find it hard to regularly give up weekend time. Weekend recreational sailing is going to come when you have the time for it, and sometime kid's soccer games and falling down houses need attention first. We have a few who are not able to do the Frostbite series because that is on the weekends. But, the weekly series things on a week night seems to offer up a way and an excuse for people who are time-stressed on the weekends to get out on the water each week. Almost like being in a bowling or softball league. I can honestly say that my sailing time would be greatly reduced if it weren't for the weekly series we run. It also offers newbies more opportunities to learn from others and reduce the frustration factors. Of course, to make this work you do need to keep the boats rigged. A lot of the folks that are cutting their teeth in our Fleet are starting to attend the region's weekend events as well. In addition, having the boats stored and rigged for the weekly racing means that they are more easily available for weekend noodle sailing. And I think learning about racing helps markedly with boat handling skills, whether they end up racing or cruising sailors in the long-run.<br><br>Keith, Annapolis, Md.
<br>H-18
<br>Northstar 500 (monoslug)
<br>www.wrcra.org
Posted By: sail-s

Re: Action and Talk, and RC Sailing - 11/07/01 05:05 PM

Just a side note that some of you may consider is using model radio (RC) controlled sailboats to introduce people to sailing. The RC sailing portion of my sailing programs has been almost as popular if not more popular than the on-the-water sailing part of my programs. On weekdays when time is limited RC sailboats work great due to quick set-up time, etc. Also we do winter sailing either on the lake or on the indoor swimming pool with wind created by 3 high output fans. Plus new sailors can do almost anything with a RC sailboat with no negative consequences, which then creates a great, desire to do on-the-water sailing. I also use a sailing simulator that one actually sits on with a real sail and again 3 high output fans to create the wind. We also use sailboats (on-the-water) that allow for the integration of sailors with and without disAbilities that has also proven popular for all. I am of course involved in disAbled sailing and for the most part most sailing organizations think sailors with disAbilities should be part of a disAbled designated sailing group, of course I totally disagree and feel everyone should sail together. The model boats I use are the RC Laser monohull and RC Wildcat catamaran. And again the boats we use for our inclusive junior, youth, and adult on-the-water sailing programs are the Access Dinghy 2.3, 303, and the Hobie 16 with or without Trapseats. I must add that I never thought the RC sailboat portion of my sailing programs would be so popular but it has proven to be extremely popular and an lot of fun for all which has resulted in increase participation and boat sales.
<br>
<br>Miles Moore
<br>www.sail-s.com<br><br>

Attached File
3652-  (18 downloads)
Posted By: heavyair14

Re: Action and Talk, and RC Sailing - 11/09/01 08:27 PM

I agree that cat sailing and all sailing is fun in general. However there are some people who try and take the fun out of it by refusing to answer questions such as which course numnber, which way to round marks etc. This makes it hard for some people to want to race at some of the events to do it without fear of being protested for a stupid error.<br><br>Hobie 14 sail #17827
<br>Hobie 16 sail #72585
Posted By: Anonymous

My Views - 11/10/01 01:09 AM

Okay, I'm going to give you my experiences and perspective
<br>as to why cat sailing has died out. I began with my first
<br>boat in the early 90's with my first used boat. Where I
<br>lived at the time, the fleet had its own beach and made for
<br>a great social environment for all cat sailors. Even at this
<br>time, I began to hear of how selfish behaviors in the racing
<br>scene were disintegrating cat sailing during the 80's as
<br>people began to get fed up with putting up with the BS from
<br>those self-interested folks that were taking over the
<br>scene at the time, thus causing people to quit the activity
<br>althogether. In the mid 90's, I moved and at one
<br>of the lakes I sailed at, I discovered a fleet that had
<br>split in two, between the serious racers and the social
<br>advocates. I tended to hang out with the social group.
<br>In the late 90's, I moved again, and it was then that I
<br>got a real education on the cat sailing scene. The lakes
<br>I sail now, I am usually the only one sailing a cat. A couple
<br>of years ago, I came in after a day of sailing and was
<br>greeted by someone that turned out to be a major member of
<br>the local fleet. I asked him where his boat was, and he
<br>replied that "I only race". He went on to talk about how he
<br>raced in the Worrell 1000 a couple of years back and all his
<br>racing experiences over the years. My only thought that went
<br>through my mind was the "this guy is the most retarded
<br>individual I have ever met".
<br>In 2000, i finally decided to enter some races with my old
<br>boat, just to get the other side of the story. I discovered
<br>a few things very interesting. For one, my old 17 foot boat
<br>was a bit of a burden. The big 20 foot cats were setting a
<br>pace for the entire day, that was leaving me completely
<br>exhausted. While they finished the courses quick and had
<br>time to rest on the beach, I struggled and had to enter
<br>the next race as soon as i finished with out any rest. I
<br>also noticed that on many races, the fleet members were not
<br>running the races themselves and were instead participating
<br>in them and leaving the work to the division reps. This
<br>appeared to be the case at every race. The fleet members are
<br>so clueless about this, that at the local fleet race here
<br>last year, the trophies were nothing but bricks and they
<br>complained about it. To much is having to be done only by
<br>the division folks to keep it going. I had heard another
<br>story during this time that the Corpus Christi fleet was
<br>shut down by the city because a total knock down and drag
<br>out fight broke out over a dispute on the ruling of a race
<br>some years back.
<br>The only fleet activity that I am interested in is participating
<br>in the annual big brothers/big sisters sailing event which I
<br>have noticed that again many "fleet" members don't participate
<br>in, making excuses of this and that. These people have closets
<br>full of trophies and it is just not enough for them. I guess they
<br>just don't get enough challenge in their professional lives
<br>and feel they have to prove their worth in the races. Well, most
<br>folks that work for a living don't want to put up with them.
<br>I think that the division heads should just quit and let
<br>everything fall to pieces instead of trying to keeping the
<br>racing scene afloat by themselves. Maybe cat sailing then would
<br>be reborn later into something better.
<br>As for me, as I have said, I am just about the only cat on the
<br>lake I sail at and that is just fine for me. I love being
<br>out alone on my cat and not putting up with the self
<br>centered morons that have destroyed the sport.
<br><br><br>

Attached File
3716-  (20 downloads)
Posted By: RobLyman

Re: My Views - 11/10/01 11:28 AM

Wow!!!!
<br>
<br>I have seen the same thing you are talking about, but not to that degree.
<br>
<br>We used to run 2 day regattas with triangle races the first day and a 10-15 mile distance race the second day. The distance race counted two races.
<br>
<br>Later on, we were pushed to make the distance race triangles because hot shot racers wanted more "competitive" racing. Our fleet died.
<br>
<br>I am not saying the racing format was the only thing that caused the decline, but I do think that it indirectly aligned with the two "camps" you mentioned.
<br>
<br>We have gotten back to our roots a bit here in Jacksonville, Florida, and managed to do what had not been done in the recent past. We now have the local Hobie fleet coming to our races on the river. The Hobie fleet is more on the social side and sails primarily in the ocean. The Hobie fleet likes the 10-15 mile distance races.
<br>
<br>I love triangle racing, but here is why I think it is bad for our sport. Most beginners start on used boats that were designed (and some built) in the early 1970s. They were designed to sail off the beach and have some upwind and downwind capability. Most experienced racers are sailing modern 18-20' racing cat, designed to go upwind and downwind VERY well. When these two types of boats get on a triangle course, the difference is like night and day. The beginners or even experienced sailors on the Hobies immediately feel like they don’t belong. As you said, they end up finishing 20 minutes later and by that time, don’t really care if they corrected out or not.
<br>
<br>The last distance race I did on my A Cat was against another A cat and 3 Hobie 18s. The lead Hobie stayed with the A Cats for most of the race and finished only 10 minutes later after 10-15 miles. At the finish, you had to tie your boat off to a float and run up to record your finish time. Everyone took their time and no one ran. It turned out that if any of the top 3 finishers had run instead of walked; the results would have been different.
<br>
<br>Last weekend I took two of the Hobie fleet sailors for a sail on the RC-27 in about 20 kts of wind. We all had a great time. It was great to hear from Cindi and Paul. Although not as “technically” accurate, the two of them had a very keen feel for the boat, wind and water. I learned from them and I hoped they learned from me.
<br>
<br>I am sorry to hear your experience has been so negative. Come on down, up or over to Jacksonville, Florida for the Gator Bowl Regatta December 1 & 2. We’ll do our best to show you a good time whether you sail a Hobie 14 or an RC-27 or anything in between. And don’t miss the Mug Race in May. The Mug Race is a 38 nm race down the St. Johns River with everything from windsurfers and Sunfish to Hobie 33 monohulls and RC-30 catamarans.
<br><br><br>

Attached File
3720-  (25 downloads)
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: My Views - 11/10/01 12:18 PM

I CANT SEE WHERE RACING TRIANGLES CAN MAKE A SPORT THAT IS WELCOMED BY ALL TO DIMINISH. YES THERE ARE GUYS WITH BIGGER FASTER BOATS AND GUYS WITH SLOWER BOATS. THIS IS WHY WE HAVE DIFFERENT CLASSES AT REGATTAS. NO MATTER WHAT THE BIG BOATS ARE DOING IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE SMALLER BOATS. YOU RACE IN YOR CLASS AGAINST BOATS WITHIN YOUR RATING AREA. I FEEL THE DECLINE IN CAT SAILING IS DUE TO LAZINESS. PEOPLE ARE IN SUCH A HURRY NOW THAT TAKING AN HOUR OUT THERE DAY TO RIG A BOAT IS JUST TO MUCH TROUBLE. PWC, KIAKS , ETC. ARE EASY , FAST , AND ALL YOU DO IS PUSH A BUTTON. I THINK IF "WE" AS SAILORS COMMIT TO PROMOTING THE SPORT OF SAILING WHICH "I" LOVE TO DO THAT WE CAN BRING IT BACK TO THE WAY IT WAS IN THE 80'S. DONT COMPLAIN AND BLAIM. PROMOTE THIS SPORT , HAVE SAILING SEMINARS WITH YOUR LOCAL YOUTH . SHOW PEOPLE IT IS NOT AS TIME CONSUMING AS THEY ALL SEE IT AS. THATS MY .02 DOUG KLEM<br><br>

Attached File
3722-  (18 downloads)
Posted By: Kirt

Re: My Views - 11/10/01 10:59 PM

Doug-
<br>I disagree here on the issue that what the "big boats" do has nothing to do with the "smaller boats". As the 500 poster said- It does quite often! Many times the RC's seem to "cater" to the "big" boats and as was expressed the "smaller" boats are expected to "like it or lump it". Many times I have seen the RC start the next flag sequence within seconds of the last, poor "little" (or oftentimes "newbie"), boat finishing giving them NO time to rest. Meanwhile the "big" boats often had time to go to the beach even! There are ways around this of course and they are employed some places but his point is perhaps we should consider that more.
<br>After all, the "races" are often set up strictly based on the concerns/needs of the "serious" racers w/ no regard to the novices/newcomers. Problem is- The "serious" racers will come back regardless but the newcomers too often decide they "don't fit in" or aren't wanted/welcome and depart the "racing scene" or fleet or cat sailing altogether.
<br>EVERY regatta ought to have something for the RANK amateur sailor and they ought to be encouraged, respected and treated like they are a VALUABLE commodity, not just a bunch of idiots who have to be "dealt with" ("Those idiots don't know what they're doing! They barged, didn't give me right of way, were trying to ask me questions, didn't hold their course, etc.!!"), IF we truly want to "grow" the sport.
<br>Problem is, I agree with one of the posters here that some of these "serious" racers are TOO SERIOUS about this RECREATIONAL ACTIVITY!!
<br>I'm sorry, I get more than enough STRESS at work, DON'T need it when I'm recreating. I find I typically end up actually sailing my cat on our local lake more than the "serious racers" who ONLY race or practice. Several even told me they DON'T like to "just sail"- That is their perogative and I don't think less of them for that but that's not why most people get into cat sailing-
<br>
<br>Later!
<br>Kirt <br><br>Kirt Simmons
<br>Taipan #159, "A" cat US 48

Attached File
3740-  (20 downloads)
© 2024 Catsailor.com Forums