Lexan is basically plastic. The difference between plastic and fiberglass rudders IS significant and noticable. I say this because I have one of each on my H16 right now.
It always seems like I'm going slower on starboard tack because I have the fiberglass rudder on the port side and therefore it's the dominant one on starboard.
"SLOWER on starboard," you say then?
Yes, and here's why: the plastic rudder flexes quite a bit more and tends to cavitate and/or stall; therefore I am forced to bear off more when I'm on port tack and so I go faster. The glass rudder is so stiff that it doesn't twist much at all (and therefore cavitate as easily) and so I tend to pinch on starboard tack. I have to think about bearing off all the time.
I'm really looking forward to building another glass rudder when I get back from the Middle East in a few months so that the dang boat doesn't act differently on port & starboard tacks.
Does my homemade rudder work as well as a commercial EPO rudder? Mebbe, mebbe not. But it cost me $40 in materials and a week's worth of evenings instead of $250, and I'm reasonably certain that it works better than a new plastic one.
The writeup on building the first one is in the H16 part of my website for your perusal. (
www.JaimeZX.com)