I gave some thought to the active and non-active ideas and I don't believe it solves any of the problems associated with the Steeplechase results. The problem lies in that the ratings are based on bouy results. If a race ends up being a reach these PN ratings are basically invalid. But most distance races don't end up being just one long reach which makes the PN numbers usually work well. I don't believe there is an adequate solution to PN number problems in distance racing unless you changed the system around totally to include the types of courses that the boats use during the race like 10% upwind, 40% reach, 30% spinnaker.

I believe a smarter split would be between spinnaker and non-spinnaker boats. This would help bring similar boats together. If the race was really a reach reach I believe a decent sailor would have won it on a Tiapan 4.9 (on corrected time).

On a final note I reviewed what boats would qualify under Mark's idea and here is the list.
Hobie Wave
Hobie 14
Hobie 16
Hobie 17
Hobie 18
Hobie 20
Hobie Tiger

Nacra 5.5 Uni
Nacra 5.8
Nacra 6.0

Inter 17R
Formula 18
Inter 20

F18HT (Bim)
Tornado
A-Cat
Shark
Isotope
Mystere 4.3?

I don't know about you but I don't think this list is makes for any fairer competition.

Just some thoughts,
Mike Hill
H20 #791