Originally Posted by Rolf_Nilsen
I have no idea why Pete posted it here and not on the open forum. Perhaps he wanted to discuss this matter with F16 sailors? I'd be just as happy to discuss this on the open forum, and that is probably where it belongs.



On the open forum, no one leads, it is one complaint after another. The F16 class is forward thinking and adaptable. Who better to lead?

A major revision of the rules would be an enormous undertaking. Since we are smaller, there would be fewer voices, hence fewer distractions. If we came up with a viable product we could, at least, propose it to the multihull council. I am not at all certain that a rule set for monohull boats is best for multihulls anyway. Think of our closing speeds!

In the worst case, such a project would involve a thorough understanding of the rationale behind the current rules. For instance: In Gil's scenario, why can't he just tack! Currently, the answer is because the rules say so! What if the rule was changed to; Hail first, tack, and then expect the boat clear astern to drop off to leeward? IMO, this is much safer in that it removes the ambiguity because there is no question of room.

Further, I am convinced that this newer rule about right of way at a gate is going to get somebody hurt. Never mind about the obligation to know the rules. Even seasoned sailors somtimes confuse port and starboard.

Last edited by pgp; 04/29/09 10:13 AM.

Pete Pollard
Blade 702

'When you have a lot of things to do, it's best to get your nap out of the way first.