So, what happened in the last race Bob?
BTW, I've been to a few rules seminars this year, as well as race management, and I've heard the "shield vs. sword" metaphor used by USSA instructors at several of them.
Matt, you attended a judge seminar, right? Did they mention it there too?
I think it would be nice if that were written right in as a fundamental rule. It would help to clarify things for everyone.
Mike