I've heard more and more bad stories about Smyth lately. A close friend of mine who is a really close friend of Randy is even questioning the ride Randy is taking them on. Not good when someone even does it to a so called friend. I dont want to go into details. I do know that Thor Jones just got a new square top for his 6.0 NA (double diamonds) from Elliot Pattison and it is top notch. E/P has done quite a few custom sq tops for 6.0s and 5.8s and one 5.5 that I have seen first hand. I would go with E/P.