Here's a variation on the theme that I got caught in this summer. Still a bit stumped on this one.

I (yellow) was coming in on starboard gybe, intending to round the left gate. Blue came in on port. I hailed starboard. He hailed inside overlap. Being the newbie, I ducked him, but wonder if I should have.


If at position 2 I was in the mark zone for the right gate, would I have had inside overlap too?