Or just dump the current report based system. Can any system be more accurate than the data fed into it?

Supporting Portsmouth is lot of work. The very nice lady who does that at USS quit a couple of years ago, but no one could be found to continue the process, so she has graciously agreed to pick it up again.

A measurement system requires less maintenance. Since no one is really happy with any of the handicap systems, why go to so much trouble? Let's take the path of least resistance.