I have sailed my whole life (mostly monohulls). Two years ago I purchased a 1985 Hobie 17 to go sailing with my son. Unfortunately I can really only use it single-handidly since I weigh 210 lbs and he is 190 and growing. First of all, with that much weight on a H17, it kills performance. Secondly, it doesn't leave much room for my other 2 children!

So I'm in the market for a cat (with a jib) that can easily carry my family. While I have never raced, my son and I would also like to start competing. So having a boat that performs well would be nice. Over the next 2 years, I expect to race (in the Philly area) about 30-40% of the time, and use the boat recreationally 60-70%.

I have my sights on a 1993 H18SX, but am also interested in a Nacra 6.0 built in 2000. The Nacra is about $500 more.

I'm interested in hearing from other sailors that sail most recreationally, but sometimes compete. What do you think would make the most sense for us? Would the Nacra be too much boat? Is it too delicate for recreational sailing? How about the TheMightyHobie18? Can it carry 4 people well? Is it too dated for racing?

I would appreciate any and all feedback - Thank You!