Thanks alot John, just what I was looking for :

Your comparison seem to run parallel to that of Stealth vs Taipan for a long way.

A few quick comments :

Quote

The hulls are the main thing I was interested in though and Matt should be very proud of his product. Scott (McCook) tells me that the VWM stem is shorter at 410mm than the 450mm shown on Phil’s plans and as built by ProSail Asia into
Agent Orange.


What do you mean exactly by this. The hulls are less high ? Or just the very front part ?


Quote

Speaking of boards, I was amazed to see that the Stealth centreboards are almost double the depth of the Blade’s but around two thirds of the width!


Here too we see two entirely different design approaches. It appears that both work. Interesting.


Quote

For my test sail this Blade was fitted with AHPC Taipan rudder blades as the owner was adapting the ones supplied by VWM. This may have had some repercussions on my test sail as I shall explain.



That is a pitty. The rudder board profile as supplied by VWM is of a noticeable better section than the AHPC ones. You would have had full control at all manouvres with the other ones. I have the AHPC ones myself and while they are generally good sections, you can make them stall (lock-up) during some more extreme manouvres. Still it; appears you had more trouble with steerage then is normal for well alligned AHPC rudders.


Quote

The Blade absolutely LOVES downwind! It’s not as solid downwind as the Stealth though, which (with its foiling rudders) simply picks up and drives with every gust.



After having raced the Stealth F16 in several day/heats I feel that no boat without T-foil rudders can feel as rock solid as the Stealth F16. You really can just ram the boat downwind and do your thing on the trampoline, the bows will simply not dig in no matter what. I don't know about the payback though (loss in speed ?) but I much rather loose some speed momentarily then risk a deep dive with possibly a capsize. I remember that during the race we eventually wouldn't even pay attention to the bow anymore. We would just round the bouy, get of the trapeze dive forward and start pulling the kite. This in itself is racing advantage in my book. On my Taipan we need to time the bear away and following actions with the movement of the bow section.

I'm absolutely convinced that the T-foil rudders are the reason for the solid feel of the Stealth. Besides John this is easy to test really. Just lend yourself a couple of daggerbaords of a fellow Stealth owners and slide this in your rudder stocks instead of the T-foil ones.


Quote

and the misaligned rudders were not a problem at lower manoeuvring speeds. At the higher powered-up-with-spinnaker speeds though the rudder issue was a bit more of a problem ...



Yep, say no more, those are AHPC rudders alright.


Quote

... With our combined weight it still took probably more than a minute for the mast to ‘unstick’ but then only seconds after that for the Blade to pop back upright. ...



A wild guess here : Your downhaul was on still tight and the top of the mast was hooking the water OR the wind = Standard Superwing behaviour and entirely preventable. The squaretop top is still standing up too much.

I've encountered this behaviour myself a few times. The rig is not cut loose enough. Run mainsheet traveller out (all the way) first, then run out as much mainsheet as there still is left, then completely slack the downhaul, possible running it out with your hand a little bit. THEN Shake the mast a little using rotation arm (mainsail will unjam herself in the mast). Now she will come up as expected. 10 seconds max. If not then release the outhaul (along the boom) as well and make sure the bolt rope is not jammed right about the goose neck.


Quote

Our pitchpole had been a biggie – we’d lost one centreplate (I recommend attaching the boards to the shrouds with a length of line and a caribine).


There should be a system to raise the boards, this should also keep the boards on board during a capsize.


Quote

... the lee bow disappearing and reappearing, and the boat barely slowing. ... think the Blade is a superb boat that feels much bigger than an F16.


It is true then. Different design approach then usage of T-foil rudders but it works.


Quote

How much of the Stealth’s downwind strength is in it’s rudders is difficult to tell- the Blade and Stealth have very different hull bottoms. But, as already mentioned on the catsailor forum, I’d really like to try the Blade with John Pierce’s latest Stealth rudders.


That may well be an excellent cross polination between the two designs.


Quote

I also thought that torsionally the Blade is not as stiff as the Stealth


I always thought the Stealth to feel much stiffer then one would expect by looking at the beams themselfs. I was surprised at that myself. I also suspect that SIN 708 can be made stiffer easily by having (halve) disk like inserts underneath the outer bolts, in both beams. See close-up of mainbeam. With this the walls of the beam are really jammed up between the inserts and the beamlanding and can't flex.


[Linked Image]




Thanks alot John,

I will from now one refer interested parties to this report.

Wouter


Attached Files
Last edited by Wouter; 03/20/06 03:36 PM.

Wouter Hijink
Formula 16 NED 243 (one-off; homebuild)
The Netherlands