When Jerry made the trade, he said the F17 is a much better single-handed boat
Hang on for a minute there !
When Jerry switched the F17 didn't even exist yet. This quote is of Jerry is getting better by the year, I do think we must put it in the right perspective.
I recall that Jerry switched mainly because the Nacra 17's had good fleet racing going on in the Michigan area while the F16's/Taipans did not. I fully support him in that decision and I also did back then. I do not recall he switched because of the reasons you write down. I think alot gets invented or added to Jerries quote.
The reasons you state about the nacra systems I find really funny. The F16's are (true) formula boats, we actively encourage sailors to modify everything to personal preference. If Jerry didn't like a particular system then he could and should have changed it.
Seven new F17s were sold by the Michigan Nacra dealer this year, and the fleet is having a great time with the F17. At last weekend's regatta, the F17 Fleet in CRAM was 2/3 of all registered boats.
And you guys are indeed having great net/forum promotion with it. CRAM is doing very well and it is very nice to see the owners being very happy with their new boats. I'm not going to talk down that. I always say publically that Nacra 17 is strong in the Michigan area, with very good fleet racing. Because that is true.
There is lots of talk about the F17 Fleet performance at the Nacra F18 World Championships where the F17 fleet started 5 minutes after the F18 Fleet and the lead boats of the F17s were working their way through the F18 Fleet and finishing consistently in the top 5 of the F18 fleet!
You had extremely light winds or some F18 sailors need some proper sail training, because there is no way that the nacra 17 boat is 5 minutes faster then the modern F18's in a normal 30 to 45 minutes bouy race. Especially not when teh nacra 17's had to work their way through a zone of dirty air when passing the fleet.
Most surprised were the F18 World Champions from Holland.
The only crew from Ned were Gunnar Larsen and his girlfriend Lisa, they never were World Champions.
Source :
1st WC F18 (2000) :
http://www.f18-international.org/2000wc.htm2nd WC F18 (2001) :
http://www.f18-international.org/2001wc.htm3rd WC F18 (2002) :
http://www.f18-international.org/2002wc.htm4th WC F18 (2003) :
http://www.f18-international.org/koksijde_2003.htm5th WC F18 (2004) :
http://www.f18-international.org/puntala_2004.htm6th WC F18 (2005) :
http://www.f18-international.org/2005goldf.htmTogether with his brother Sacha Larsen, Gunnar was 20th at the last F18 WC and 7th Dutch team from the top. His current F18 ranking is 94 (taken over results in 2005). I don't think Lisa is even listed.
Source :
http://www.f18-international.org/erl_listbyname.htmHis last Dutch F18 championship participation was in 2003. I don't think he sailed any championship with Lisa as crew before this Nacra F18 event. Still they appeared to dominate the Nacra F18 world championship with only Alex and Nigel staying close.
Source :
http://www.nacraclass.com/PRW05/Results%20Day%205.htmI'm sorry, no disrespect intended to any individual sailor, they are all good sailors, but the Dutch team was no where near being the F18 world champions. And even though they are currently the NACRA F18 world champions I think we would do well to realize how much deeper the skill level truly is of the many European teams that didn't participate in this event.
They had not seen the F17, a completely different boat than the N17 marketed in Europe.
And that is very good because the EU I-17 is one slow boat. It has the questionable honour to be the only spinnaker equipped boat to be thrown in with the Hobie 16 / Prindle 16 open class fleets.
I wonder what would have happened if Matt had competed at last year's Championships.
Is this proof of Matt ability to sail or the nacra 17 superiority ?
So Michigan racers picked the Nacra F17 and all involved believe they made the right choice.
Very good, best of luck to your guys. Honestly.
On a different level however, on class building, I say your are about 4 continents and over 100 boats short. Growth rate is at best 1/4 of ours. I would love to race you guys in this arena as well, makes for a fun challenge I think. But you need to do better then you are doing now and I say that without any emotion. For me, class building is a game of strategy and I now got all the pieces of this chessboard were I want them. A few more years and the game will have been played and the outcome will be known. You'll have to enter the game now or it is just a matter of time.
Therefor I invite you guys to provide us with a challenge. I'm looking forward to that.
Wouter