| New Centreboards #215709 07/10/10 08:04 PM 07/10/10 08:04 PM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hi all, am about to make a major modification to Thrice Bitten.  Have purchased a set of couple of year old design, A class Flyer centreboards and cases  , which I am going to get put into my 15 year old Faye hulls (it currently has very wide, wider than boyer centreboards)  . No surprises that I will get them installed as far back as possible (which is where the back of the current cases is), the interesting bit is that I intend to get them installed vertically (most Mossies angle them back the maximum 10 degrees), so what do you think? | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#215710 07/10/10 08:20 PM 07/10/10 08:20 PM |
Joined: Apr 2007 Posts: 432 McCrae Y.C. Mornington Peninsu... Simon C
addict
|
addict
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 432 McCrae Y.C. Mornington Peninsu... | Hi Gary, 10 degrees forward, port canted out 35 degrees, starboard canted in 26 degrees... Might give me a chance to catch you some time  On a more serious note... what's the thinking behind verticle? Is it because they were that way in the Flyer or do you have a theory? Cheers
Simon Taipan AUS341
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Simon C]
#215716 07/10/10 11:43 PM 07/10/10 11:43 PM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hi Simon, why would you imagine I would have a theory?  Well it does seem that all cats that do not have measurement restrictions on distance back that centreboards are placed built in recent years, have vertical centreboards and that incudes the Flyer ones I have bought. As far as I can see the only reason for raking centreboards back is when you want to move your Centre of Lateral Resistance further back and rules do not allow it. I am hoping that the smaller centreboards vertical will not move CLR forward much if any at all, as the rudder blades will actualy account for a larger pecentage of the CLR, than previously, helping to balance the fact that the tip of the centreboards will be further forward. Now for the theory  . When sailing long sailboards with swinging centreboards as the wind increased we found a effect we called railing up. This was caused by depressing the lee rail of the board on purpose which as the speed increased resulted in the centreboard lifting the board out of the water and helping it to plane, it also allowed you to point higher as you balanced the forces of the increased lift from the centreboard. No surprise I hear you say, you where using the centreboard as a lifting foil.  When the wind increased it would flip the board over, to stop this we would rake the centreboard back. My theory, raking centreboards back reduces lift  . On sailboards we use to even rake them forward in light winds, which increased lift even more, but made them very hard to control  . So there you have it, I hope to get more lift which should improve windward performance  . But expect it will make the boat twitchier? something I am willing to live with, I hope | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#215756 07/12/10 06:15 AM 07/12/10 06:15 AM |
Joined: Jul 2010 Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD Damo
journeyman
|
journeyman
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD | Hi Guys I'm new to the Mosquito class and I have just started to build my first one. I was Just reading your thread about boards and was wondering if you could point me in the right direction is there a reconmended board and rudder width and length that most people use other than the specs on the rules form? Thanks
Last edited by Boat name TBA; 07/12/10 06:22 AM.
Damien 1820 Raw Prawn (under construction)!!! QLD
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Damo]
#215758 07/12/10 06:39 AM 07/12/10 06:39 AM |
Joined: Jan 2006 Posts: 556 Somers, Westernport Bay, Victo... Peter_Foulsum
addict
|
addict
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 556 Somers, Westernport Bay, Victo... | Hi TBA and welcome to the swarm.  I hope that your building all goes to plan and you have your new Mozzie on the water for the start of next season.  Where do you plan to sail/race and what is your sail number ? Any details would be greatly appreciated for addition to the Mozzie register. If you don't want to make it public just send me a PM through this forum site. In terms of centreboard width and length there are many variations but most have a width of around 250 mm and a length just greater than 1 m. My current centreboards are 10 inches wide by 1020 mm long. These were cut down from the original timber boards which were much wider and longer and I have seen no adverse effects. Regards, Peter
Mosquito 1814 Macka Mozzie
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#215760 07/12/10 07:03 AM 07/12/10 07:03 AM |
Joined: Jan 2006 Posts: 556 Somers, Westernport Bay, Victo... Peter_Foulsum
addict
|
addict
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 556 Somers, Westernport Bay, Victo... | Hi Gary, My ancient Mozzie had vertical boards and when I made the change to the 10 degrees rake it made made an enormous difference.  That little shift in the centre of lateral resitance appeared to reduce the weather helm significantly and allowed me to set the rudders up close to vertical. I also reduced the width at the same time so that may also have had some effect. Mind you the aft edge of the centreboard case is not as far rearward as the modern Mozzie so that could account for some difference (3305 mm versus 3353 mm allowable) Jeremy Pearse did some experimentation with "A" class centreboards without much success. Not sure if they were 9" wide but they just didn't have the same tracking ability as the 10" boards. I'm sure Jeremy could give you some clarification. Regards, Peter
Mosquito 1814 Macka Mozzie
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Peter_Foulsum]
#215761 07/12/10 07:06 AM 07/12/10 07:06 AM |
Joined: Jul 2010 Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD Damo
journeyman
|
journeyman
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD | Thanks for the reply and feed back Peter. Sail number 1820 (on the plans any way)I currently skipper a Nacra 5.8 out of Cleveland yacht club in Brisbane while i build the Mozzie but I live on the Gold Coast so when the boat is built probberly both places at this stage. I bourght an old hull mould from Jim Boyer recently and the hulls will be under way shortly, I know they are an older design mould but for my first boat these will do fine. Your tips on the foils are much appreciated, I can start to work on these in between the hulls. Time is my biggest problem at the moment so I'll just keep ticking along Thanks once again and look foward to joining the Mozzie clan Cheers Damien
Last edited by Damo; 07/12/10 07:34 AM.
Damien 1820 Raw Prawn (under construction)!!! QLD
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Damo]
#215821 07/13/10 01:30 AM 07/13/10 01:30 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hi all, my new boards are 220 x 1005, effective length 550 under the hull. Old boards where 290 x 965, effective length 510 under the hull. No doubt placing cases as far back as legal in hull is essential, vertical as opposed to raked 10 degrees I guess I will find out.  or | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Matt_Stone]
#215824 07/13/10 04:09 AM 07/13/10 04:09 AM |
Joined: Mar 2010 Posts: 77 Gippsland Lakes mitchellsailor
journeyman
|
journeyman
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 77 Gippsland Lakes | Matt you're on the right track, but in fact it is I that have just bought the new sail :P. Time will tell if this is to beat you, Gary or both hahaha.
Mosquito 1750 Bonnie-GLYC / Peninsula
The plan was simple.... Like my brother in law Phil, except this plan just might work!
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: mitchellsailor]
#215922 07/15/10 12:46 AM 07/15/10 12:46 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hi M & M, my theory is never stop trying to go faster  . If I keep moving the goal posts hopefully you whipper snippers won't kick any goals  . Oh I have ordered new rudders also.  | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: mitchellsailor]
#216492 07/26/10 04:02 PM 07/26/10 04:02 PM |
Joined: Jul 2010 Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD Damo
journeyman
|
journeyman
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD | Hi Guy's Thanks for the tips on the board sizes. Before I start you wouldnt have sudgestions for rudders as well? When I build the boards I can make the rudders at the same time, any help would be graitfull Thanks once again Regards Damien
Damien 1820 Raw Prawn (under construction)!!! QLD
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Peter_Foulsum]
#216559 07/28/10 01:53 AM 07/28/10 01:53 AM |
Joined: Jul 2010 Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD Damo
journeyman
|
journeyman
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 87 Gold Coast QLD | Hey Peter please check you PM Thanks Damien
Damien 1820 Raw Prawn (under construction)!!! QLD
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: DickenCider 1777]
#217748 08/17/10 06:02 PM 08/17/10 06:02 PM |
Joined: Mar 2003 Posts: 943 East Gippsland, Australia Tim_Mozzie
old hand
|
old hand
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 943 East Gippsland, Australia | Hi AJ Good to see you on the forum at last.
Gary is planning to put them back to the max measurement, but not raked. Because they are narrower than the ones we have been using that also helps get the CofE a bit further back. Overall his CofE may end up slightly forward of the current boats but it is going to be very close.
It's just a question of whether the possible gains from having them vertical will outweigh any disadvantage from moving the CofE slightly forward. We will see...
Tim Shepperd Mosquito 1775 Karma Cat
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: DickenCider 1777]
#217799 08/19/10 12:03 AM 08/19/10 12:03 AM |
Joined: Jun 2004 Posts: 502 Port Noarlunga, SA, Australia Darryn
addict
|
addict
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 502 Port Noarlunga, SA, Australia | I reckon a Mozzie would fit in alright at Cairns yacht club. I had a look at there site, seems to be some cat sailing going on at Ellis beach. I raced my Mozzie in Townsville, mostly dinghys there back then. I have not heard of the spirit of the class rule. I cant place where that is defined either. Personally I find the class to be progressive, compared to Lasers and Flying Fifteens which I now race too, the Mozzy Associations are open to new ideas and practical, sensible proposals which wont obsolete the entire fleet overnight are voted in at AGM's. I just copied and pasted this out of the constitution "Promote the development of the Mosquito class catamaran and control the building rules and class restrictions to ensure consistency" Nothing about spirit their. You could always go this path with your new ideas. "A member may propose an alteration to the plans, specifications and/or restrictions by submitting a notice of motion detailing such alteration to the State/Territory Association for endorsement and forwarding to the National Association" Which, you know, gets voted on by the members. http://home.vicnet.net.au/~nmcca/doc/Mosquito_BRR.pdf http://home.vicnet.net.au/~nmcca/doc/NMCC_Measurement_Form.pdf I heard the big stick is still in use  Darryn
Last edited by Darryn; 08/19/10 12:41 AM. Reason: grammar, spelling, plenty more too
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Darryn]
#217800 08/19/10 12:35 AM 08/19/10 12:35 AM |
Joined: Mar 2003 Posts: 943 East Gippsland, Australia Tim_Mozzie
old hand
|
old hand
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 943 East Gippsland, Australia | Darryn's got all the right links there. Nothing of any consequence has changed in them for a couple of decades. The racing is very good here in Vic as well. It's always a tough race at the front of the fleet. Helped by the fact that all the new boats are pretty much identical. The "Spirit of the rules" sounds more like an opinion or state of mind than a rule. I imagine it would get mentioned if someone built something wacky and tried to call it a Mosquito. I mean a set of rules as simple as the Mosquito's are always going to have a hole or a weakness somewhere which would mean something completely off-the-wall could be built without breaking them - but what would be the point? Most of us sail Mosquitoes for the competition, the social side, and for the pleasure of sailing a boat that simply works. There's not much point going to all the trouble of building a boat just to prove there are flaws in the rules. Might as well build an F16 where anything goes. The tall rig never went anywhere. It was obvious early on that the mast section would have to be replaced as well - leading to a sequence of inevitable changes which would have ended up with the Mozzie turning into the Taipan (again). No point
Tim Shepperd Mosquito 1775 Karma Cat
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: DickenCider 1777]
#217802 08/19/10 02:47 AM 08/19/10 02:47 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | I am so tempted. just to test this "spirit of the class" bull##it rule I had thrown at me. I guess I can give certain individuals something to ban or outlaw. I do have some very interesting ideas and yet again it will test the waters. Not many Mozzies up here in cairns so I can secretly invent new ways in private. Is the big stick issue dead??? Hope so. who has a copy of the building regulations? have they been updated?? any new design changes I should be aware of?? Cheers. AJ I believe there is a F16 in Cairns now, if you want to test theories that is the class to do it, nothing more interesting in Mossies than fitting vertical centreboards which A's did a million years ago. | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: DickenCider 1777]
#217803 08/19/10 03:23 AM 08/19/10 03:23 AM |
Joined: May 2007 Posts: 416 Matt_Stone
addict
|
addict
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 416 | I am so tempted. just to test this "spirit of the class" bull##it rule I had thrown at me. I guess I can give certain individuals something to ban or outlaw. I do have some very interesting ideas and yet again it will test the waters. Not many Mozzies up here in cairns so I can secretly invent new ways in private. Is the big stick issue dead??? Hope so. who has a copy of the building regulations? have they been updated?? any new design changes I should be aware of?? Cheers. AJ The new boats these days are the max dimensions, and they have been performing really well. But its the sailors that actually picked up the game. the hot competition here in vic is that hot that made the class generally have become quicker. and neally all boats are the same. To me my personal opinion i dont like a class like the the "A-Class" and "f16" cos there are too many options and veribles. i like the boats the same and it comes down to the sailor on how they sail the boat and strategies and tactics. Matt Unko 1816 | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Simon C]
#220961 10/06/10 02:18 AM 10/06/10 02:18 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hey you can't rush boat builders, still waiting on it being finished, hoping to sail it at Club Opening this weekend. | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: DickenCider 1777]
#221055 10/06/10 04:09 PM 10/06/10 04:09 PM |
Joined: Aug 2009 Posts: 117 Cairns FNQ engineer
member
|
member
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 117 Cairns FNQ | I am so tempted. just to test this "spirit of the class" bull##it rule I had thrown at me. I guess I can give certain individuals something to ban or outlaw. I do have some very interesting ideas and yet again it will test the waters. Not many Mozzies up here in cairns so I can secretly invent new ways in private. Is the big stick issue dead??? Hope so. who has a copy of the building regulations? have they been updated?? any new design changes I should be aware of?? Cheers. AJ Hi Mate, I race at Tinaroo, would love to see a Mozzie up there!!!! I've always been intrigued by the "mini tornado", nice classic timeless lines. beautiful boats. Chocko
Nacra 430 Rocket
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: engineer]
#221229 10/07/10 04:20 PM 10/07/10 04:20 PM |
Joined: Jan 2007 Posts: 81 To windward of you! Sixth Element
journeyman
|
journeyman
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 81 To windward of you! | "mini Tornado"????
im pretty sure the tornado (before rig change anyway) is a mossie on steroids, i mean the mossie is older so they must have copied us..lol
Last edited by alegayter_mossie; 10/07/10 04:20 PM.
"Sixth Element" 1782 MK2 w/spinnaker. Lake Bonney Y.C. National Sec. / S.A President / S.A Measurer / Commodore LBYC
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Sixth Element]
#221247 10/08/10 01:56 AM 10/08/10 01:56 AM |
Joined: Aug 2009 Posts: 117 Cairns FNQ engineer
member
|
member
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 117 Cairns FNQ | Hi mate, Yeah, the T was released after the Mozzie. Why no square tops yet? they would be amazing with a square top and a kite!!! I might even be convinced to try one. Chock
Nacra 430 Rocket
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: engineer]
#221256 10/08/10 04:09 AM 10/08/10 04:09 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hi mate, Yeah, the T was released after the Mozzie. Why no square tops yet? they would be amazing with a square top and a kite!!! I might even be convinced to try one. Chock Well and truly got the kite  , don't need the square top, the heavy mast to hold it up would slow the boat down too much  . | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#221358 10/10/10 02:57 AM 10/10/10 02:57 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hi all, centreboards worked brilliantly, Frecheville & Heeney boat builders did a great job. Looks really solid and a great fit around the boards allows very litte water in the case. No gurgling no humming, just the sweet feel of less drag  , boat balanced just as it used to and steering felt more responsive  . Now for the new rudder blades, hopefully they will arrive this week, but will be a few weeks before fitting  , as I have to make up push rods and fittings. Did 2 races yesterday in around 15knots of breeze. 6 mossies raced, 3 x Spin, 2 x sloop and 1 cat. I won both races  . Was a awesome first days sailing for the season, will be hard to get a better day  . | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#221397 10/10/10 11:54 PM 10/10/10 11:54 PM |
Joined: Mar 2003 Posts: 943 East Gippsland, Australia Tim_Mozzie
old hand
|
old hand
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 943 East Gippsland, Australia | I should add to Gary's report on his first two races and say that he completely demolished Peter and myself - upwind and down. We were there, chasing, but nowhere near him. We have some work to do!
Of course Peter and myself both failed the winter boat maintenance test which didn't help. Off the start line for the second race we both sheeted on to the sound of loud bangs. My gooseneck bolt snapped (15 years old - not bad), and Peter's mainsheet strop exploded - well vapourised really, as only the ends were left!
Tim Shepperd Mosquito 1775 Karma Cat
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#221675 10/15/10 12:02 AM 10/15/10 12:02 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Hi All, new Rudder Blades from the Fibreglass Factory S.A. (Tony Barrett). Arrived today  , beautifully finished like all his work  . Love the shape of them  , from the same mould as Niel Joiner's. Just have to get them fitted up now  . | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#221692 10/15/10 09:36 AM 10/15/10 09:36 AM |
Joined: May 2008 Posts: 107 Melbourne, Australia MitchB
member
|
member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 107 Melbourne, Australia | About three weeks ago you tried to tell me that Snow Skiing was more expensive than Sailing Gary.....
Stingray #579 GLYCish
| | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Simon C]
#221781 10/17/10 01:54 AM 10/17/10 01:54 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | OK you don't have to rubb it in guys  . Yes a new boat doesn't look so expensive now, specialy after the centreboard cases  . | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#222069 10/19/10 03:50 PM 10/19/10 03:50 PM | Scarecrow
Unregistered
| Scarecrow
Unregistered | Question about how everyone is using their boards. When you pull them up down wind do you just give them a tug or have you carefully marked a line where they are flush with the bottom and lift them to that point each time? | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#222088 10/19/10 07:35 PM 10/19/10 07:35 PM |
Joined: Oct 2010 Posts: 2 michaelspar
stranger
|
stranger
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 2 | The Sailor are the really one who pick up the game. --------------- Gifts for Men | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: ]
#222102 10/20/10 01:51 AM 10/20/10 01:51 AM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | Question about how everyone is using their boards. When you pull them up down wind do you just give them a tug or have you carefully marked a line where they are flush with the bottom and lift them to that point each time? Usualy I have just pulled on rope, which I think has allways left some hanging out the bottom. Most Mossie centreboards I have seen have been cut with a angle on the bottom, which doesn't match the bottom of the boat, leaving some angle hanging out the bottom at least. My new centreboards leave quite a bit out the bottom when you pull on the rope, as they are longer than normal mossie boards, I may muck around pulling up to the bit where they start to taper to the elliptical tip in light winds, depends on what is going on around me I think. | | | Re: New Centreboards
[Re: Fat Bomber]
#224122 11/14/10 06:44 PM 11/14/10 06:44 PM | thricebitten
Unregistered
| thricebitten
Unregistered | No haven't changed mast rake at all yet. | | |
|
0 registered members (),
3,459
guests, and 106
spiders. | Key: Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod | | Forums26 Topics22,406 Posts267,062 Members8,150 | Most Online3,694 2 hours ago | | |