I'm partial to the Hobie 18 and admit that I'm not too familiar with the Nacras and other brands. If you've already got sailing experience, it will be no different to learn on than a Hobie 16, actually probabaly a little easier because the likelyhood of pitchpoling is a lot lower. Also tacking is easier, and the roller furling jib provides a quick way to depower. The 18 is often described as the cadillac of beach cats because it's fast yet robust, relatively easy to sail, and can easily handle up to three adults - a great all around cat.

The cracks around the crossbars are an issue that really only pertains to boats built between 1984 and 1988. Also, the method for preventing and/or fixing them is pretty well established for boats built during that era, so I would not let that dissuade you.

As far as righting the boat, around 300lbs minimum is recommended for a Hobie 18. However, you can do it with less is you use a righting bag, pole, or other assisting device.


sm