Originally Posted by samc99us

Incorrect on the N20 issue Dave. The fleet voted not to open up the sail plan at Spring Fever in 2010, with the Nacra appointed class president present (so a real vote), then half the fleet left and showed up with F18's the next year. The N20 class didn't open up sail development, and still hasn't (EP and Performance sails are the only class legal Nacra 20 One Design sails approved), just the south came up with a Open 20 rule and Texas came up with another and the West Coast is sailing Glasers...it's all fractured with no leadership. I had skin in the game at the time of the 2010 vote, so yes, I am well aware of what happened on the N20 front. There were certainly other issues at play, Nacra having financial troubles at the time, new Nacra under European ownership could care less about the N20 (F18 is the popular boat in Europe), effectively no new N20's built post 2006/07, mast costs being an issue, and the big killer, the class association just died. No one to run the class or drum up event support is what nailed the lid on the coffin of an otherwise great boat. And that is a common story with bleeding edge technology, single-manufacturer one design boats.



Thank you for the clarification Sam. The point is mucking with the boat even thought it was a splinter group did not save the class and in fact likely hastened its death. If there is a better mouse trap out there then trying to make your class "like" that mouse trap isn't going to save it. The F18 class has never been about the boat and quite honestly the boat aint that great and never has been. To this day I still have F16 sailors telling me why the F18 sucks, like I'm not aware I'm one dragging the beast up the beach! The F18 class has always been about stability and keeping old boats pretty much competitive. It's a great formula that isn't broken in my opinion. Foiling is a fad. :-) (thinking of you Mr Curry)



David Ingram
F18 USA 242
http://www.solarwind.solar

"Do or do not. There is no try." - Yoda
"Excuses are the tools of the weak and incompetent" - Two sista's I overheard in the hall
"You don't have to be a brain surgeon to be a complete idiot, but it helps"