Bob,
I like the latest set of rules far better than the original set. Mainly because I prefer lighter boats.

I would like to raise some personal comments for discussion.

I like the idea of not restricting any puerly downwind sail. Like spinnaker of hooter provided they are not used upwind. Luff length is more important than straight out area and luff length will be limited by mast height which will feed back into Boat and crew weight in average sailing conditions.

To prevent the competative sail plans from becoming so big that the class is beyond the capabilities of the younger sailor a sliding scale of boat weight and working sail area could help satisfy many of the concerns raised as an alternative to totally open.

People still have the freedom to experiment within a very broad scope looking at the best combination for their crew weight and personal preferences. At the same time it would help keep the competition reasonabley close.


Just a thought.

I know that the voices in my head aint real,
but they have some pretty good ideas.
There is no such thing as a quick fix and I've never had free lunch!