Personally, I find the discussion interesting, although it would be better if there were some facts available. Without facts, it just keeps going in a circle.
However, the premise is interesting. I'm still not sure why there is so much antagonism about it.
I think it is about money. The F16 has filled an existing niche and caused the devaluation of some boats. IMO, the 17 and 18 footers are just too heavy for a significant number of sailors. Speaking purely subjectively, my choices for a new boat, in order of preference were A class, F16, and Wave. I rejected the 17s and 18s for weight alone.
