Something that I see in the threads above is a distinct line in the sand. An either/or condition, black/white.

A deep personal look inside Division 4 (Pacific Northwest)last year showed a full spectrum of sailor types.
We've got Forumula, OD, Adventure, and Portsmith hardcore race only sailors. All the way over to, camp on the beach, I just want to reach all day and drink something in my free hand types.

Our challenge as leaders is to facilitate the organization to at least sustain membership, and to hopefully grow and strengthen. Respecting the differences, and finding a balance is the only way I see to make this work.