If the USCG approval process wasn't completely retarded like apparently it is - then I'd be in favor of using the USCG-only prescription. However - to say that Lotus jackets are non-USCG because they took the previous design and changed the embroidery on it and therefore lost their USCG approval - is stupid and reflects the ham-fisted, bureaucratic, red-tape heaven that is governmental regulations.

Likewise, the approval process is quite costly AND is quite lengthy. By the time a USCG approval is given, the jacket is obsolete.

I've been wearing a CE vest for at least a year now and I never had a problem with it supporting my 235lbs butt even when there was a 75oz full camelpak bladder in the back pocket.

The INTENT of the rule (IMO) governing the use of floatation devices is to make sure that someone doesn't show up with some sytrofoam tied to their arms with fishing line and claim that they have adequate safety measures. I don't think it was meant to exclude a whole 75% of the marketed, safe life jackets out there today.