Matt, Perhaps I missed something, but I was under the impression there were wind speeds taken before the race, and that the Pro and RC were in compliance with the rules. If they failed to record/log them I can see how someone with a motive might want to get the race thrown out. I can also see that people might respect the positions of said Pro and RC, and let their judgement stand. I don't see it as simply following the rules, and there is obviously some gray in the interpretations of the rules! While I don't know squat about racing, I have heard the protests, and arguements around the bar after regattas. Many come from the same people time and again. This sort of protest still looks bad from where I sit. You say the readings weren't taken, and weren't recorded. I heard that readings were taken before the race, and that they had the required 5. As I read the rules, that fulfills the requirement. Am I wrong?